WBAUnofficial
Bloody NIMBY’s… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Bloody NIMBY’s… (/showthread.php?tid=43313)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Derek Hardballs - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 11:40 AM)Øssian Wrote: B1 & BB, thankfully I have no idea what the contents of the OP were/are, but you're both responding to the board equivalent of the village pisshead. Someone who wanders into the bar, sees that there are no arguments going on, so tries his hand at starting a spurious one.

It's become beyond tiresome.

You don’t know what the contents of the thread are, but you clicked on the thread, then went to effort of clicking on the reply button, then replying to the thread to simply to post an insult. Thank heavens you didn’t engage.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - baggy1 - 11-11-2026

The ghost of SunDog is amongst us Big Grin


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Derek Hardballs - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant local and national government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

(11-11-2026, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The ghost of SunDog is amongst us Big Grin

B1 isn’t about now that you start lecturing others about how constructive and decent you are?


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - baggy1 - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

Possibly the most 'I haven't read the post' post we've had in a while


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Derek Hardballs - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 01:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

(11-11-2026, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The ghost of SunDog is amongst us Big Grin

B1 isn’t about now that you start lecturing others about how constructive and decent you are?

(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

(11-11-2026, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The ghost of SunDog is amongst us Big Grin

B1 isn’t about now that you start lecturing others about how constructive and decent you are?

Possibly the most 'I haven't read the post' post we've had in a while

Erm you’re confusing me not reading the post with Oss apparently not reading the thread but still taking the effort to post on it.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - baggy1 - 11-11-2026

Arf, check again


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Protheroe - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

Tell me you don't understand the concept of zoning without telling me you don't understand the concept of zoning.

Wigan has not "scrapped" a number of "similar schemes" as it would not be in their power to do so. They may have scrapped proposed employment designations but not those they have already designated.

If the nature of HS2 is not for the "benefit of communities" can you explain to me why it is pretty much a tunnel and deep cutting from London all the way to Water Orton? And therefore the most expensive railway per mile in the world? 

Local voices have plenty of say in the development of Local Plans. Generally they don't want anything near them, which is the most absolutely selfish and unsustainable position it's possible to take - and ultimately self defeating. 

Let me give you an example about where I live; Bromsgrove is nearly 90% Green Belt. Bromsgrove has under supplied housing sites in two previous Local Plan Periods. Bromsgrove has no brownfield sites whatsoever. Bromsgrove has issued a draft Local Plan for consultation. Every single one of the sites has a local action group against it - usually led by craven Councillors who know they have previously undersupplied housing sites.

The result - every single site around Hagley, including those not even proposed by Bromsgrove Council now has a speculative planning application from a developer. Bromsgrove now has to determine these applications BEFORE it publishes its Local Plan otherwise every developer will appeal against non-determination using the previous under supply as a argument, let alone future under supply. It's likely that Hagley will end up with MORE houses than if residents had worked with developers, and makes it more likely they will be in locations that are less suitable.

Multiply this by every other local authority district in the country.

Selfish, irrational people like you are the problem.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Borin' Baggie - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant local and national government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.


We've not had zoning since just after the second world war, it was superseded by our system of planning permission which is what enabled this monstrosity to be built adjacent to a housing estate.

And our former zoning system used to be based on municipal boundaries i.e. local government. It's what enabled the massive amount of civic buildings in Birmingham to be built.


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Derek Hardballs - 11-11-2026

(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant local and national government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

(11-11-2026, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The ghost of SunDog is amongst us Big Grin

B1 isn’t about now that you start lecturing others about how constructive and decent you are?

(11-11-2026, 01:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-11-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Wigan Council designates site as prime employment land in decades old UDP - before housing was built. LA searches would have revealed this to everyone who subsequently proposed to buy a house. People in houses order all sorts of stuff online rather than going to the shops. Logistics developer builds prime warehouse building to serve rapidly expanding home shopping market. Wigan Council grants consent on designated prime employment everyone knew about. If they hadn't then developer would have won on appeal.

Bev Craig, Burnham's successor as Greater Manchester mayor, said she too was concerned. “Old industry wouldn’t have got that close to your house”  -  with a statement like that I can only assume that Bev Craig has never visited Greater Manchester let alone Birmingham & the Black Country.

Sorry to burst your bubble Dekka, but BB is right. Zoning would have ruled this out - when I was in development Labour Councils had an obsession with mixed-use development, this is just an example of it.

‘Zoning’ didn’t solve any problems as the council have said they complied with the rules as they are. You start stripping local voices out of planning with greedy developers and compliant government departments and this is what happens. Wigan have only scrapped a number of other similar schemes due to the backlash this monstrosity of a development has caused and the hard work of residents to not be silenced. 

Every decision in this country seems to be around maximising profit, not for the benefit of communities. Just because something is within the rules does not mean it’s ethical or right.

Tell me you don't understand the concept of zoning without telling me you don't understand the concept of zoning.

Wigan has not "scrapped" a number of "similar schemes" as it would not be in their power to do so. They may have scrapped proposed employment designations but not those they have already designated.

If the nature of HS2 is not for the "benefit of communities" can you explain to me why it is pretty much a tunnel and deep cutting from London all the way to Water Orton? And therefore the most expensive railway per mile in the world? 

Local voices have plenty of say in the development of Local Plans. Generally they don't want anything near them, which is the most absolutely selfish and unsustainable position it's possible to take - and ultimately self defeating. 

Let me give you an example about where I live; Bromsgrove is nearly 90% Green Belt. Bromsgrove has under supplied housing sites in two previous Local Plan Periods. Bromsgrove has no brownfield sites whatsoever. Bromsgrove has issued a draft Local Plan for consultation. Every single one of the sites has a local action group against it - usually led by craven Councillors who know they have previously undersupplied housing sites.

The result - every single site around Hagley, including those not even proposed by Bromsgrove Council now has a speculative planning application from a developer. Bromsgrove now has to determine these applications BEFORE it publishes its Local Plan otherwise every developer will appeal against non-determination using the previous under supply as a argument, let alone future under supply. It's likely that Hagley will end up with MORE houses than if residents had worked with developers, and makes it more likely they will be in locations that are less suitable.

Multiply this by every other local authority district in the country.

Selfish, irrational people like you are the problem.

Are you defending the development in Wigan? How can it be ok to put huge warehouses next to houses and then operate those sites 24/7? Which is what the company wanted to do and was doing until the residents stood up against them. They still only get 6 hours grace when it closes under the new proposal. Can you tell me in this specific case where any proper public consultation or even mitigation was put in place BEFORE the developer and council agreed to build these awful developments. 

There are plenty of brownfield sites across the BC that have sat unbuilt upon for years in some cases decades. Look at the old police station site in Walsall, they knocked it down at least eight years ago, still nothing built there. 

Going back to your original point, planning permission was according to the council obtained within the rules for the site, which anyone can see is unsuitable for such a development alongside housing. Or flip this and ask how houses could be given planning permission, knowing full well in a few years time the potential for a huge warehouse would be placed next to their houses?

Thats not proper development it’s profiteering from house buyers by one developer and riding roughshod over those who bought the houses by another. Placing the two next to each other is awful planning and development… I bet it made the billionaire land owner lots of money run though, you probably know him by his first name Wink


RE: Bloody NIMBY’s… - Øssian - 11-11-2026

I just clicked 'Show this post' and got this...

''You don’t know what the contents of the thread are, but you clicked on the thread, then went to effort of clicking on the reply button, then replying to the thread to simply to post an insult. Thank heavens you didn’t engage.''

It is possible to open a thread without seeing the OP, if that poster is on ignore. I just gambled that the opening salvo was probably fired from yet another tranche of imaginary moral high ground; the odds were favourable. My engagement was with B1 and BB alone.

Everything subsequent remains mostly opaque, as I still haven't seen the OP and nobody has re-quoted it. My loss...