WBAUnofficial
PSR breach reported by John Percy - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: PSR breach reported by John Percy (/showthread.php?tid=41270)



RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - CA Baggie - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

Fair play for answering FF properly. You've certainly set a president that the rest of us should instead of taking the piss.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Duffers - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 06:36 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

Fair play for answering FF properly. You've certainly set a president that the rest of us should instead of taking the piss.

Yeah most people Barack him for his views.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - MrBater - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

If it's a loophole then they can't really do us for it, they've let enough other clubs get away with loopholes. Then they can close it for next year...JFK, sorry AFAIK that's the way it is...


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - RamsAy it - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

There were no provisions on the balance sheet for either loans when Patel settled them. 

The loan to Lai was fully written off and Baldies loan was still on the balance sheet with no provision against it.

Patel injected money to pay back Lai's loan, which had a 100% benefit to PSR

After the legal decision, Patel had to pay Baldies loan, else that would have had to have been written off, again a 100% benefit to PSR.

So, Patel injecting money to pay the MSD interest is no different, as all three actions were purely to benefit PSR.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 04-15-2026

Leave. It. To. Prag.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - CIM - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 07:29 PM)RamsAy it Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

There were no provisions on the balance sheet for either loans when Patel settled them. 

The loan to Lai was fully written off and Baldies loan was still on the balance sheet with no provision against it.

Patel injected money to pay back Lai's loan, which had a 100% benefit to PSR

After the legal decision, Patel had to pay Baldies loan, else that would have had to have been written off, again a 100% benefit to PSR.

So, Patel injecting money to pay the MSD interest is no different, as all three actions were purely to benefit PSR.

So that means in layman's terms...?


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Malcolm Tucker - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 07:29 PM)RamsAy it Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

There were no provisions on the balance sheet for either loans when Patel settled them. 

The loan to Lai was fully written off and Baldies loan was still on the balance sheet with no provision against it.

Patel injected money to pay back Lai's loan, which had a 100% benefit to PSR

After the legal decision, Patel had to pay Baldies loan, else that would have had to have been written off, again a 100% benefit to PSR.

So, Patel injecting money to pay the MSD interest is no different, as all three actions were purely to benefit PSR.

This is complete and utter bollocks. 

The loan was not written off - it was impaired to zero, due to not being deemed recoverable. Once the obligation to pay the loan was either transferred to Patel or paid in full as part of the sale, the reversal of that impairment hit the P&L. 

Recharging a normal P&L interest cost to the owners is totally different.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - RamsAy it - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 07:46 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 07:29 PM)RamsAy it Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 06:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-15-2026, 02:24 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: There seems a massive inconsistency here re the MSD interest

If the MSD interest cannot be taken out of the PSR equation, how come Lai’s loan (that had been written off was paid back to the club by Patel) and allowed to be included in the PSR calculation as reducing the losses.

Likewise, how was Patel allowed to repay Baldies loan, so that it wasn’t written off and been a hit on the PSR?

I think the club should use the above as a president for allowing Patel to take on the interest on the MSD loans and have it allowable to reduce losses for PSR.

The two are totally different. One is the reversal of a provision against a debtor and the other is a standard standard P&L expense that we’ve tried to recharge to a related party. The fact that they both relate to loans is totally irrelevant. 

I would imagine the EFL are arguing that this is a back door way of Patel injecting extra equity above whatever the permitted level is.

There were no provisions on the balance sheet for either loans when Patel settled them. 

The loan to Lai was fully written off and Baldies loan was still on the balance sheet with no provision against it.

Patel injected money to pay back Lai's loan, which had a 100% benefit to PSR

After the legal decision, Patel had to pay Baldies loan, else that would have had to have been written off, again a 100% benefit to PSR.

So, Patel injecting money to pay the MSD interest is no different, as all three actions were purely to benefit PSR.

This is complete and utter bollocks. 

The loan was not written off - it was impaired to zero, due to not being deemed recoverable. Once the obligation to pay the loan was either transferred to Patel or paid in full as part of the sale, the reversal of that impairment hit the P&L. 

Recharging a normal P&L interest cost to the owners is totally different.

Go back and check the accounts, as there was no debtor for the loan  It was an off balance sheet asset. 

Repaying the Lai loan is, in my opinion, more dubious than paying the MSD interest, as the Lai loan no longer existed in the accounts.

As I mentioned above, the motive for repaying Lai's and Baldies loans and the MSD interest was purely to benefit PSR and nothing else.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - wba13 - 04-15-2026

Why all this speculation, the truth will come out. By what the media are saying the EFL want it sorted by the end of the month which is doubtful as if it doesn’t go in our favour there will legal challenges which all take time. So let’s just see what happens
Instead of one financial advisor debating who right against another financial advisor.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - HeggebøsBarnDoor - 04-15-2026

(04-15-2026, 08:21 PM)wba13 Wrote: Why all this speculation, the truth will come out. By what the media are saying the EFL want it sorted by the end of the month which is doubtful as if it doesn’t go in our favour there will legal challenges which all take time. So let’s just see what happens
Instead of one financial advisor debating who right against another financial advisor.

Because it's a massive fuck up and expecting people not to speculate is like spotting one of your neighbours shagging the milkman and trying to keep it to yourself.