WBAUnofficial
So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... (/showthread.php?tid=12370)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - MassDebater - 09-05-2020

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-54036637

You can't claim whatever race you like? Seems a bit unfair given that a man can say he's a she or vice versa. What if a white man knows deep inside that he is really a black woman who only wants Latino women?

Surely there is some sort of correlation between claiming race and claiming a gender?

is race really about the colour of your skin, or like gender nowadays, a fluid thing?


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - baggpuss - 09-05-2020

In protest over this I will be doing our walk later in a dress and going blackface!  Big Grin


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Psalm23 - 09-05-2020

Mark me down as in the couldn't give a fuck camp.   Rolleyes


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - baggiebloke - 09-05-2020

Do we have to Drag Race into this?


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - baggy1 - 09-05-2020

The worlds gone mad Tom, however I would put it like this - your race is defined by other people (your parents / ancestors) whereas your gender would be defined by you (who you are / how you feel).

I don't necessarily agree with it as a principal but would look at each individual case rather than allow a blanket 'yes you have to allow anybody to do what they want'. Some examples (males / former males competing in female sports) don't sit right and need to be monitored. If a man wants to be a woman that should be enough for them, they don't need to then immediately step into the woman's arena of sport (as an example)


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - MassDebater - 09-05-2020

(09-05-2020, 09:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The worlds gone mad Tom, however I would put it like this - your race is defined by other people (your parents / ancestors) whereas your gender would be defined by you (who you are / how you feel).

I don't necessarily agree with it as a principal but would look at each individual case rather than allow a blanket 'yes you have to allow anybody to do what they want'. Some examples (males / former males competing in female sports) don't sit right and need to be monitored. If a man wants to be a woman that should be enough for them, they don't need to then immediately step into the woman's arena of sport (as an example)

Interesting thoughts.

Totally agree regarding the sport thing, but can't see how they'll moderate it moving forward.

Race seems to be the last definition controlled externally, since you can already change your sex, religion and nationality. Just need to allow blondes to identify as brunettes and gingers to claim that they don't smell of pisd and we're all equal. Guess it'll be height and weight next.

I'm a fatty, but I'm identifying as slim, am gonna sue clothing makers, I identify as a 32 waist...why won't they fit my lardy ass???!


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Bear Town Baggie - 09-05-2020

A friend of mine is mixed race, she's very white, her father is black. Even she is confused about what she is supposed to say or not.


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - SW4Baggie - 09-05-2020

(09-05-2020, 09:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The worlds gone mad Tom, however I would put it like this - your race is defined by other people (your parents / ancestors) whereas your gender would be defined by you (who you are / how you feel).

I don't necessarily agree with it as a principal but would look at each individual case rather than allow a blanket 'yes you have to allow anybody to do what they want'. Some examples (males / former males competing in female sports) don't sit right and need to be monitored. If a man wants to be a woman that should be enough for them, they don't need to then immediately step into the woman's arena of sport (as an example)

Sex and race are biological.
Gender is social, cultural and individual.


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - CA Baggie - 09-05-2020

(09-05-2020, 09:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The worlds gone mad Tom, however I would put it like this - your race is defined by other people (your parents / ancestors) whereas your gender would be defined by you (who you are / how you feel).

I don't necessarily agree with it as a principal but would look at each individual case rather than allow a blanket 'yes you have to allow anybody to do what they want'. Some examples (males / former males competing in female sports) don't sit right and need to be monitored. If a man wants to be a woman that should be enough for them, they don't need to then immediately step into the woman's arena of sport (as an example)

Those biology lessons at school were a waste of bloody time then!  I thought it was all to do with chromosomes and fertilisation from sperm to the egg. 

Bloody Peoples Front of Judea.


RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - SW4Baggie - 09-05-2020

(09-05-2020, 10:19 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(09-05-2020, 09:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-05-2020, 09:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The worlds gone mad Tom, however I would put it like this - your race is defined by other people (your parents / ancestors) whereas your gender would be defined by you (who you are / how you feel).

I don't necessarily agree with it as a principal but would look at each individual case rather than allow a blanket 'yes you have to allow anybody to do what they want'. Some examples (males / former males competing in female sports) don't sit right and need to be monitored. If a man wants to be a woman that should be enough for them, they don't need to then immediately step into the woman's arena of sport (as an example)

Sex and race are biological.
Gender is social, cultural and individual.
Well that concept of gender was introduced in the 50s and started to gain traction in the 70s but it did not mean this for most of human history. And we somehow survived. Not saying it isn't progress to have these new definitions and understandings for affected groups in society, and it is good for everyone to be aware, just don't think we should be spending so much time on it and entertaining any and all ideas. I/we blame social media.

And up until the 70s everyone was happy, no one had to repress their true selves, battle mental illness and anxiety without support and just get on with it...

Social media has given everyone a voice and without doubt created a pressure for everyone to need to be special. I entirely agree so much of this is driven by a desperate need for people to be relevant, but society becoming more tolerate and accepting has been beneficial for a lot of people and groups too.