WBAUnofficial
Handball rules - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Handball rules (/showthread.php?tid=12924)



Handball rules - Beachboysbaggie - 09-28-2020

Horrendous as they are, I wonder if they might be good for teams like us. You’d normally expect the better teams to get the most pens, by spending more time in opposition penalty areas. And you’d expect the benefit of any doubt to go with the bigger clubs with refs swayed by larger crowds and big reputations. Now all judgement is removed and all it takes is ball to touch arm or hand, surely that’s a great leveller? You don’t have to be the better team to do that.


RE: Handball rules - Duffers - 09-28-2020

Didn’t help us on Saturday.


RE: Handball rules - Beachboysbaggie - 09-28-2020

(09-28-2020, 05:33 PM)Duffers Wrote: Didn’t help us on Saturday.

True. I was thinking more over the course of a season rather than just the one match


RE: Handball rules - Peachy - 09-28-2020

(09-28-2020, 05:24 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Horrendous as they are, I wonder if they might be good for teams like us. You’d normally expect the better teams to get the most pens, by spending more time in opposition penalty areas. And you’d expect the benefit of any doubt to go with the bigger clubs with refs swayed by larger crowds and big reputations. Now all judgement is removed and all it takes is ball to touch arm or hand, surely that’s a great leveller? You don’t have to be the better team to do that.

My worry with all this is that it's going to change the game for the worse. Managers will now start telling their players to just blast the ball at the defenders arms/hands at every given opportunity. So rather than a risky shot at goal players will now start looking to win handball decisions.

Fucking ridiculous. What is wrong with the intentional handball rule? Its so obvious when someone tries to stop it. Especially with video replays. 

It needs sorting pronto.


RE: Handball rules - CA Baggie - 09-28-2020

(09-28-2020, 05:24 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Horrendous as they are, I wonder if they might be good for teams like us. You’d normally expect the better teams to get the most pens, by spending more time in opposition penalty areas. And you’d expect the benefit of any doubt to go with the bigger clubs with refs swayed by larger crowds and big reputations. Now all judgement is removed and all it takes is ball to touch arm or hand, surely that’s a great leveller? You don’t have to be the better team to do that.

Not so sure.

Do you think Chelsea's 3rd goal would have been given if the roles had reversed?  Maybe I'm paranoid about the power of influence and the institutional bias towards the big clubs but I think there's not a chance we'd have got it.

Their forward handled the ball in our box and within 3 seconds the ball is in the net, if that isn't deemed immediacy then they need to clarity the rules.  Was it because Kanu scuffed the clearance, if the forward had passed it would it have still been allowed? 

Does anyone actually know?

What I do know is that clever forwards will just look to play the ball at stray arms at any given opportunity.

The law is an ass and if this interpretation is what the law makers actually aimed for then they can fuck right off with their rolexs and brown paper bags and ruin some other sport, because that's what it's doing - ruining football.


RE: Handball rules - billybassett - 09-28-2020

David Elleray wrote the new rule for IFAB. Tells your all you need to know


RE: Handball rules - Tom Joad - 09-28-2020

CA Baggie Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Horrendous as they are, I wonder if they might be good for teams like us. You’d normally expect the better teams to get the most pens, by spending more time in opposition penalty areas. And you’d expect the benefit of any doubt to go with the bigger clubs with refs swayed by larger crowds and big reputations. Now all judgement is removed and all it takes is ball to touch arm or hand, surely that’s a great leveller? You don’t have to be the better team to do that.

Not so sure.

Do you think Chelsea's 3rd goal would have been given if the roles had reversed?  Maybe I'm paranoid about the power of influence and the institutional bias towards the big clubs but I think there's not a chance we'd have got it.

Their forward handled the ball in our box and within 3 seconds the ball is in the net, if that isn't deemed immediacy then they need to clarity the rules.
  Was it because Kanu scuffed the clearance, if the forward had passed it would it have still been allowed? 

Does anyone actually know?

What I do know is that clever forwards will just look to play the ball at stray arms at any given opportunity.

The law is an ass and if this interpretation is what the law makers actually aimed for then they can fuck right off with their rolexs and brown paper bags and ruin some other sport, because that's what it's doing - ruining football.

Them's my thoughts n'all. I fear there is plenty enough confusion in the guidelines to achieve any outcome. Just look at this weekends chaos.


RE: Handball rules - Beachboysbaggie - 09-28-2020

(09-28-2020, 07:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
CA Baggie Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:Horrendous as they are, I wonder if they might be good for teams like us. You’d normally expect the better teams to get the most pens, by spending more time in opposition penalty areas. And you’d expect the benefit of any doubt to go with the bigger clubs with refs swayed by larger crowds and big reputations. Now all judgement is removed and all it takes is ball to touch arm or hand, surely that’s a great leveller? You don’t have to be the better team to do that.

Not so sure.

Do you think Chelsea's 3rd goal would have been given if the roles had reversed?  Maybe I'm paranoid about the power of influence and the institutional bias towards the big clubs but I think there's not a chance we'd have got it.

Their forward handled the ball in our box and within 3 seconds the ball is in the net, if that isn't deemed immediacy then they need to clarity the rules.
  Was it because Kanu scuffed the clearance, if the forward had passed it would it have still been allowed? 

Does anyone actually know?

What I do know is that clever forwards will just look to play the ball at stray arms at any given opportunity.

The law is an ass and if this interpretation is what the law makers actually aimed for then they can fuck right off with their rolexs and brown paper bags and ruin some other sport, because that's what it's doing - ruining football.

Them's my thoughts n'all. I fear there is plenty enough confusion in the guidelines to achieve any outcome. Just look at this weekends chaos.

There’s a lot less uncertainty than there was, as rubbish as it is it has to be a leveller. Put it this way, imagine if we had it in the Champ last year, dominating a game but always dreading a ball ricocheting onto an arm