WBAUnofficial
Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review (/showthread.php?tid=17365)

Pages: 1 2 3


Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 05-09-2021

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-56461679

Mandelson is convinced that it is Corbyn which put voters off, not remainers like him. I think the former didn't help,; Corbyn and his Islington/Camden mindset advisers might not have enamoured themselves to voters in some places but I still think moving to a 2nd referendum position was more damaging. It would be interesting to see if there's any polling on this of ex-Labour voters.

Meanwhile, Mandelson is the one who said, in 1998, that the party didn't need any more 'Horny-handed' working-class members 'In dirty overalls' and thought the working class could be treated with contempt because, "Where else do they have to go?"

And he wonders where the votes went.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Squid - 05-10-2021

It's a clear double-whammy. Corbyn + not getting behind Brexit has been disastrous for Labour and I say that as a remainer.

I know some will say that backing Brexit is a triumph of populism over what's best for the country, but I think they aren't seeing just what an unpopular argument "We need to stay in Europe or the EU will economically ruin us" is.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Derek Hardballs - 05-10-2021

(05-10-2021, 06:09 PM)Squid Wrote: It's a clear double-whammy. Corbyn + not getting behind Brexit has been disastrous for Labour and I say that as a remainer.

I know some will say that backing Brexit is a triumph of populism over what's best for the country, but I think they aren't seeing just what an unpopular argument "We need to stay in Europe or the EU will economically ruin us" is.

But if you believe that it will be harmful and you’re a politician or prospective politician then the only alternative is to lie to approx half the population that you think it was a good idea or say we shall try and make the most of it.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 05-10-2021

The Parliament which legislated for the referendum is obviously different composition-wise since 2017 to the one which legislated for the referendum but I think that if any MP voted for the referendum in the 2015 Parliament they should not have voted to try to block the implementation of the result in subsequent ones. If they thought leaving would lead to great harm they should not have voted for the referendum to be held to begin with. I know that doesn't address your MPs' quandry, Derek, I am just thinking aloud on a related matter.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - ChamonixBaggie - 05-11-2021

Mandelson can fuck off. The manifesto itself was pretty popular IIRC, it was obviously the successful smear campaign against Corbyn and being seen - right or wrongly - as anti-Brexit that did for them. The Tories have nicked policies from the manifesto so it can't have been that bad!

Squid and Dekka have touched upon a difficult subject. What do you do? Suck it up, abandon your principles and essentially lie by saying that you're behind Brexit or that you're anti-immigration knowing that it's the smart play for electoral success. Or stick to what you think is right, knowing that it will probably lead to electoral failure. Do ends justify the means? I don't have the answer.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 05-11-2021

Corbyn is a Brexiter, I have no doubt about that. The party's shift to a 2nd referendum - driven mainly by Starmer, I think - is what did for them. Some of the claims about Corbyn were possibly overblown but I don't think it can all be waved away as smears.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Borin' Baggie - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 08:35 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Corbyn is a Brexiter, I have no doubt about that. The party's shift to a 2nd referendum - driven mainly by Starmer, I think - is what did for them. Some of the claims about Corbyn were possibly overblown but I don't think it can all be waved away as smears.

The Labour Party shifted towards a second referendum because they were polling around and below the Lib Dems, were on track to get absolutely decimated (as in, a Liberal Party-esque collapse to sub-100 seats) and it was easier than embracing Brexit as the Conservative voters were more definite to vote Conservative than the Lib Dem and Green voters.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Protheroe - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 06:46 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The manifesto itself was pretty popular IIRC

Can we just put this myth to bed?

In 2019 the Labour Party had its worst result since 1935. The manifesto may have been popular with middle class London based Labour chatterati members who make up the vast majority of the modern party - but it was wholly unpopular with the electorate.


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - ChamonixBaggie - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-11-2021, 06:46 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The manifesto itself was pretty popular IIRC

Can we just put this myth to bed?

In 2019 the Labour Party had its worst result since 1935. The manifesto may have been popular with middle class London based Labour chatterati members who make up the vast majority of the modern party - but it was wholly unpopular with the electorate.

Really?

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/tactical-voting-blog/labour-manifesto-policies-popular-polling-nationalise-tax-rising-a9214276.html

https://labourlist.org/2019/11/how-popular-are-labours-radical-manifesto-policies/

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2019/11/12/labour-economic-policies-are-popular-so-why-arent-

https://www.bmgresearch.co.uk/bmg-independent-labour-policies-popular-but-many-want-change-in-direction/

The manifesto wasn't - and isn't - the problem


RE: Mandelson: Starmer needs policy review - Protheroe - 05-11-2021

(05-11-2021, 10:34 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The manifesto wasn't - and isn't - the problem

Good grief. There is a world of difference between telling a pollster or focus group that "free stuff" is "good thing" and then actually voting for it.

Surely to God, December 2019 taught you that? If not, I fear there's no hope for you?

Also, take the question on Rent Control - did anyone explain what Rent Control actually did to the privately rented market by the end of the 1970s? "Good things" need to be set in the context of whether they actually work.