WBAUnofficial
Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative (/showthread.php?tid=31921)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Derek Hardballs - 12-04-2023

Speaking as someone who is centre, probably not even centre left, I do find Labours latest attempt at becoming Tory light depressing. Currently the message is more of the same policies that have given millions of people little hope for over a decade. By fawning all over dyed in the wool Tories they are in danger of talking for granted their core voters to the point they just won’t bother voting. I’m less than enthusiastic it has to be said. 

Wanging on about change and then offering no real difference is an interesting tactic and those who point to the mills to say that it’s working are deluding themselves that its support for Labour rather than absolute antipathy towards the Tories. That support even if they win the election will evaporate very quickly if Labour are determined to offer Tory lite policies that offer no hope to millions of people for the next five years.


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Protheroe - 12-04-2023

I thought you supported honesty in politics?

As it stands Starmer looks likely to be the #leastworst in 2024. He will lose that crown even more quickly if he decides to tax, spend and borrow even more than this shower.


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Ted Maul - 12-04-2023

Starmer is a cunt. It's a shame I'm having to give such consideration to not voting in the next election as for once I think our local candidate is really good.


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - CaptainFantastico - 12-04-2023

Genuine question. Given the lack of credible candidates, if Burnham was leader (appreciate he is not currently an MP), do you think Labour would come out better or worse at the next election.

I ask this because this thread and others seems to be the standard grievance that you get with anyone that can ever lead Labour to a general election win. By nature of the UK (at the moment) they have to be centrist or very close. I'm not sure who else anyone thinks would make a better option, given that reality


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Ted Maul - 12-04-2023

(12-04-2023, 09:30 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuine question. Given the lack of credible candidates, if Burnham was leader (appreciate he is not currently an MP), do you think Labour would come out better or worse at the next election.

I ask this because this thread and others seems to be the standard grievance that you get with anyone that can ever lead Labour to a general election win. By nature of the UK (at the moment) they have to be centrist or very close. I'm not sure who else anyone thinks would make a better option, given that reality

Burnham would have been my pick for leader post-Corbyn.


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Protheroe - 12-04-2023

(12-04-2023, 09:30 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuine question. Given the lack of credible candidates, if Burnham was leader (appreciate he is not currently an MP), do you think Labour would come out better or worse at the next election.

I ask this because this thread and others seems to be the standard grievance that you get with anyone that can ever lead Labour to a general election win. By nature of the UK (at the moment) they have to be centrist or very close. I'm not sure who else anyone thinks would make a better option, given that reality

Bodybags as leader would've tacked back to the centre as Starmer has. It's inevitable if Labour ever wants to win a majority.

Personally I can't stand the fella after Mid Staffs
https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/chris-skidmore/mid-staffordshire-andy-burnham_b_2970110.html


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Derek Hardballs - 12-04-2023

(12-04-2023, 09:30 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuine question. Given the lack of credible candidates, if Burnham was leader (appreciate he is not currently an MP), do you think Labour would come out better or worse at the next election.

I ask this because this thread and others seems to be the standard grievance that you get with anyone that can ever lead Labour to a general election win. By nature of the UK (at the moment) they have to be centrist or very close. I'm not sure who else anyone thinks would make a better option, given that reality

I’m cynical and pragmatic enough to realise you have to be in the centre to win an election, but currently the Labour leadership are content it seems to play a game of whose got the biggest willy competition on any subject the Daily Mail deems important. There is no rational arguments for their position they are backing themselves into either, cut immigration, ok who’s doing those jobs then? Making the shite that is Brexit work better! Ok then, how are you going to keep on board the rabid right you are trying to woo? There isn’t a workable solution that will appease them. Punish the poorest for the mistakes of the richest with draconian and invasive Benefit sanctions. Ok that helps who? What are you trying to achieve with these performative gestures? 

How many comfortably well off Boomers and shire folk do they really think they are going to attract, and even if they do, retain past one term in office, without losing their core vote? Currently Labour offer nothing but the same depressing and failing solutions at best, and at worst they are backing themselves into a corner where they have to be even more extreme just to keep borrowed votes onside. Medium term madness in the hope of short term gain.

They aren’t the same as Blair, Blair offered people hope, a vision and something to be positive about and regardless of circumstances Labour currently offer feck all but more misery, a lack of bravery and contempt for their core voters.


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - CaptainFantastico - 12-04-2023

(12-04-2023, 10:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-04-2023, 09:30 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuine question. Given the lack of credible candidates, if Burnham was leader (appreciate he is not currently an MP), do you think Labour would come out better or worse at the next election.

I ask this because this thread and others seems to be the standard grievance that you get with anyone that can ever lead Labour to a general election win. By nature of the UK (at the moment) they have to be centrist or very close. I'm not sure who else anyone thinks would make a better option, given that reality

I’m cynical and pragmatic enough to realise you have to be in the centre to win an election, but currently the Labour leadership are content it seems to play a game of whose got the biggest willy competition on any subject the Daily Mail deems important. There is no rational arguments for their position they are backing themselves into either, cut immigration, ok who’s doing those jobs then? Making the shite that is Brexit work better! Ok then, how are you going to keep on board the rabid right you are trying to woo? There isn’t a workable solution that will appease them. Punish the poorest for the mistakes of the richest with draconian and invasive Benefit sanctions. Ok that helps who? What are you trying to achieve with these performative gestures? 

How many comfortably well off boomers and shire folk do they really think they are going to attract and even if they do retain past one term in office, without losing their core vote? Currently Labour offer nothing but the same at best at worst they are backing themselves into a corner where they have to be even more extreme just to keep borrowed votes onside.

You only have to look what's happening now when a party gets elected on borrowed votes. I think that's the nature of the countries demographic and the issue with the archaic political system

(12-04-2023, 10:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-04-2023, 09:30 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuine question. Given the lack of credible candidates, if Burnham was leader (appreciate he is not currently an MP), do you think Labour would come out better or worse at the next election.

I ask this because this thread and others seems to be the standard grievance that you get with anyone that can ever lead Labour to a general election win. By nature of the UK (at the moment) they have to be centrist or very close. I'm not sure who else anyone thinks would make a better option, given that reality

Bodybags as leader would've tacked back to the centre as Starmer has. It's inevitable if Labour ever wants to win a majority.

Personally I can't stand the fella after Mid Staffs
https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/chris-skidmore/mid-staffordshire-andy-burnham_b_2970110.html

Can only say what my Uncle (lifelong Tory) who works very closely with him says, and he's a huge admirer and full of praise for the bloke


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - Shabby Russian - 12-04-2023

It will be interesting to see at the next election, if turnout in inner city seats significantly fall.

Are Labour about to take for granted another constituent if their core support on the assumption they have no alternatives for their vote.

Labour will win the next election, but it wouldn't surprise me if they did so with less votes than they got in 2017....it actually wouldn't shock me if they won getting less votes than they did in 2019.

Looking forward it concerns me that there will be no serious left of centre option for UK voters and that there will be a nationalist right wing option that feeds on that void.


RE: Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative - CaptainFantastico - 12-04-2023

(12-04-2023, 11:04 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It will be interesting to see at the next election, if turnout in inner city seats significantly fall.

Are Labour about to take for granted another constituent if their core support on the assumption they have no alternatives for their vote.

Labour will win the next election, but it wouldn't surprise me if they did so with less votes than they got in 2017....it actually wouldn't shock me if they won getting less votes than they did in 2019.

Looking forward it concerns me that there will be no serious left of centre option for UK voters and that there will be a nationalist right wing option that feeds on that void.

Agree with some of that but the reason they are in such a strong position is because they've traded those that wanted to vote for them in the last 2 and still will by and large this time (but with less conviction) for those that didn't last time but now will. And it's hard to argue that that is anything but the best approach, given the cards they hold