WBAUnofficial
Compulsory National Service - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Compulsory National Service (/showthread.php?tid=33887)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


Compulsory National Service - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-25-2024

To be reintroduced if the Tories win.

How badly does their campaign have to be going before they promise to bring back the death penalty?


RE: Compulsory National Service - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-26-2024

They can only appeal to the hardship-fetashists and the hard of thinking.


RE: Compulsory National Service - Shabby Russian - 05-26-2024

Did we not bring you Brexit?

Did we not renege on our commitment to net zero?

Did we not distort the housing market, making it difficult for the young to ever own their own home.

Did we not crash the economy leaving the young to pick up the bill.

Our record of achievement over the last 14 years is there for all to see.

If you hate your children and/or grand children then vote Conservative.


RE: Compulsory National Service - Protheroe - 05-26-2024

So you haven’t read the article, and you’re not aware that similar schemes are being introduced in those Far Right countries Sweden, Norway & France?

As it stands Proth Major has been volunteering for 2 years as part of her DofE. It’s been beneficial to her and to the younger kids she’s been working with.

Cynicism is a British disease, I’m often very guilty of it myself. However it’s also worth noting that when this idea was mooted a few years back 3 times as many young people supported it than opposed it.


RE: Compulsory National Service - Derek Hardballs - 05-26-2024

The DofE scheme is voluntary and you can volunteer for organisations you already attend. So sport, dance etc. This proposal forces kids to work for free in the NHS, Fire and charities…

The YouGov poll says 68% are opposed to the idea.

Oh and from Ben Kentish…

Cost of compulsory national service: £2.5bn a year.

Cost of pay rise for junior doctors that ministers insist is “simply unaffordable”: £2bn a year.


RE: Compulsory National Service - Logic1 - 05-26-2024

(05-26-2024, 06:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: So you haven’t read the article, and you’re not aware that similar schemes are being introduced in those Far Right countries Sweden, Norway & France?

As it stands Proth Major has been volunteering for 2 years as part of her DofE. It’s been beneficial to her and to the younger kids she’s been working with.

Cynicism is a British disease, I’m often very guilty of it myself. However it’s also worth noting that when this idea was mooted a few years back 3 times as many young people supported it than opposed it.
Funny that you support the freedom to choose when it comes to the market but not the freedom of an 18 year old to choose to do military service or not. Guess you're not really a real liberal.


RE: Compulsory National Service - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-26-2024

(05-26-2024, 06:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: So you haven’t read the article, and you’re not aware that similar schemes are being introduced in those Far Right countries Sweden, Norway & France?

As it stands Proth Major has been volunteering for 2 years as part of her DofE. It’s been beneficial to her and to the younger kids she’s been working with.

Cynicism is a British disease, I’m often very guilty of it myself. However it’s also worth noting that when this idea was mooted a few years back 3 times as many young people supported it than opposed it.

Yes, I read the article. Why would you assume I hadn't? Why is it relevant that other countries are considering it?


RE: Compulsory National Service - Derek Hardballs - 05-26-2024

(05-26-2024, 07:41 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(05-26-2024, 06:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: So you haven’t read the article, and you’re not aware that similar schemes are being introduced in those Far Right countries Sweden, Norway & France?

As it stands Proth Major has been volunteering for 2 years as part of her DofE. It’s been beneficial to her and to the younger kids she’s been working with.

Cynicism is a British disease, I’m often very guilty of it myself. However it’s also worth noting that when this idea was mooted a few years back 3 times as many young people supported it than opposed it.
Funny that you support the freedom to choose when it comes to the market but not the freedom of an 18 year old to choose to do military service or not. Guess you're not really a real liberal.

I wonder if you’re wealthy if you can opt out? Pay a fine or something and hey presto Tabitha and Tristan are exempt. 

Free labour for positions that should be paid positions….


RE: Compulsory National Service - Borin' Baggie - 05-26-2024

Populist nonsense designed solely to pander to the kind of people that only exist to hate young people, the only way to make this fair is to apply it to everyone over the age of 18 that didn't do national service and I'd start with the 79 year olds.

Unaffordable, uncosted, ill-thought out based on Cleverly flailing about over it this morning and the armed forces do not want to babysit a bunch of 18 year olds that don't want to be there.


RE: Compulsory National Service - Fido - 05-26-2024

Although I'm not really in favour per se there are some elements of this that could make sense if done in the right way, probably more in the community service area. 

There are loads of kids, many of whom are from underprivileged backgrounds, who know as far as the boundaries of there own towns and that's about it. But on the flip side there are those with far more means that keep very much to their social circles and don't see the issues that others may face. School and academia might not necessarily be something that comes naturally to some so opening up options, giving an idea of self-worth within a community is not necessarily a bad thing. 

With something like the DoE is that more often that not it's a suggestion by parents to have something to "put on the CV" and some kids would never see that as an option for themselves. I'm not sure what the take up is population-wise but would guess it's relatively small. There is a case to say that having something like this in place, with activities between mixes of kids from different backgrounds would be a way of broadening horizons for all. I know most will see this as solely a way of instilling discipline via the military route but it could be a lot more than that.