WBAUnofficial
"He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" (/showthread.php?tid=35604)

Pages: 1 2 3


"He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Lurker#3 - 11-09-2024

I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Birdman1811 - 11-09-2024

Indeed Lurker, so much training time is spent on shape, players know roughly where each other player is at all times, more you tinker with that shape, more passes go astray, more runs are missed.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Ted Maul - 11-09-2024

Enough of the tactical drivel. They should just go out there with the freedom to do as they please, entertain me and wallop everyone 4-0.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-09-2024

If that’s that case I think some of our players need to learn how to recognise what a triangle looks like. It may be a crazy way to look at geometry and I get that it might be too much for their little brains. But it’s a great way to pass the ball and create. Basics.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Cheshire East Baggie - 11-09-2024

There's no doubt that CC tries different things as matches develop. I think he leaves it too late to change, and there are things where he's been obstinate, in particular persisting with Josh on his own up front or subbing him and trying to close a match out without any sort of centre-forward.

What he's never done as far as I can remember is start a match with a different shape. We saw early season how getting ahead early in a game releases the shackles, settles the nerves etc. But now we never go for it early, the "plan A" shape doesn't get us in the lead. So try something different.

A massive smokescreen of excuses, reasons and justifications has been thrown up on the bored this week. Carlos is getting the popular backing from the thinking fan on here that (for instance) Alan Irvine never got. That's as it should be but make no mistake, we need a win, we desperately need to not lose a match before we get a win, otherwise it will get very ugly for Carlos. Only he can fix it by getting the players to do things that work.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - GunsOfNavarone - 11-09-2024

(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.

I was beginning to think I'd imagined the in game changes to the formation. Phew.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - HLS - 11-09-2024

As much as I disagree with Hawks' overall sentiment, our early season form had plenty of players wanting the ball and coming close to get it and make those triangles but we've not done it so well during this blip. Perhaps Hawks is right, back to working on triangles might help.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Tom Joad - 11-09-2024

(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.

C'rect. Also there is the Furlong moving inside ploy. It ain't radical but it is a case of tinkering here and there. Remember, Thursday night was not a game to lose and Burnley were making a good fist 2nd half of trying to win. There are changes during play but one thing we can't change is that the attacking players are out of form, another is our lack of an effective no.10. For all of their talents, Swift is a yard slow and Grady is forever lightweight both in physique and in his passing. I still believe there is nothing radically different in these players other than a drop in confidence.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Bristol Baggie - 11-09-2024

(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.

PlayStation knowledge post that pal

Mowatt, Swift and Grant have all hit double figures goal wise at this level

We could support  Maja better - he’s as isolated as Rondon under Pulis currently 

We could go more direct in the last 20

We could stop having all 11 defending corners

We could stop fucking about with goal kicks 

CC is the man for us, but he is too rigid at the moment (Biesala has the same issue)


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - TartanRug - 11-09-2024

(11-09-2024, 05:39 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.

PlayStation knowledge post that pal

Mowatt, Swift and Grant have all hit double figures goal wise at this level

We could support  Maja better - he’s as isolated as Rondon under Pulis currently 

We could go more direct in the last 20

We could stop having all 11 defending corners

We could stop fucking about with goal kicks 

CC is the man for us, but he is too rigid at the moment (Biesala has the same issue)

Agree with some of that Bristol. Definitely need to get more players around Maja when he gets the ball.

I think we have gone more direct at times but it hasn't paid off so far.

Some won't like it but probably the stats show that the benefit of having 11 defending corners outweigh the benefit of leaving 1 or 2 up front.

I don't mind us playing out from the back at goal kicks, just think we need to move the ball more quickly with more one touch passing when we get it in the opposition half, we will probably give the ball away more but will pull the opposition out of shape and create more openings - for example Heggems chance at Blackburn was created through a quick one touch lay off from Maja