WBAUnofficial
John Healey resigns - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: John Healey resigns (/showthread.php?tid=41770)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


John Healey resigns - CIM - 06-11-2026

Left with no option that to submit my resignation letter’ after failing to secure the funding he says necessary for the defence investment plan...

The priority of any government is the defence of the nation. Concerning that welfare spending seems to be a bigger priority.


RE: John Healey resigns - baggy1 - 06-11-2026

Welfare spending including pensions you mean. Pensions amount to £147bn of the £330bn spent on welfare, I'm guessing you're ok with pensioners getting their pensions or do you suggest we increase the state pension age? The defence budget extra amount requested was £28bn, that would mean that other (non-pension) benefit payments would have to be cut by about 15%. Alternatively we could raise Income Tax. Which one would you suggest?


RE: John Healey resigns - CIM - 06-11-2026

(06-11-2026, 11:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Welfare spending including pensions you mean. Pensions amount to £147bn of the £330bn spent on welfare, I'm guessing you're ok with pensioners getting their pensions or do you suggest we increase the state pension age? The defence budget extra amount requested was £28bn, that would mean that other (non-pension) benefit payments would have to be cut by about 15%. Alternatively we could raise Income Tax. Which one would you suggest?

If we're serious about increasing defence spending without touching pensions, there are options within welfare:
• Reinstate the two-child cap: ~£3bn
• Reverse the free school meals expansion: ~£1bn
• Housing benefit reforms: ~£1.5–2bn
• Disability/incapacity benefit reforms: £5bn+
• Tighten the household benefit cap: up to £1bn
• Means-test Child Benefit further: £1–3bn
• Reduce fraud and error: £1–3bn
Total potential savings: roughly £13.5–18bn a year


RE: John Healey resigns - baggy1 - 06-11-2026

You’re still £10bn short and that’s only if all of things would be implemented and I’m guessing that you are approaching pension age due to the reluctance to hit pensioners in those savings.

And guessing you don’t have kids of school age - wild guess


RE: John Healey resigns - CIM - 06-11-2026

(06-11-2026, 12:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You’re still £10bn short and that’s only if all of things would be implemented and I’m guessing that you are approaching pension age due to the reluctance to hit pensioners in those savings.

And guessing you don’t have kids of school age - wild guess

I do. We're not rich but can afford to give them a bowl of cereal each morning.
I'm not a million miles off pension age. I suspect the triple lock may need to end but pensioners do need protection.
Potentially another £3–5bn+ a year can be saved on green subsidies without abandoning net zero entirely—simply slowing the timetable or reducing subsidies.


RE: John Healey resigns - Protheroe - 06-11-2026

Like pensions, social care, housing and student debt the government has stark choices on defence. John Healey believes they’ve made the wrong choice.

At least they’re consistent.


RE: John Healey resigns - man in the corner shop - 06-11-2026

Oh dear
Another hefty kick in the nether regions for the bloke who isn't very good at politics.


RE: John Healey resigns - Borin' Baggie - 06-11-2026

You're halfway to getting to 3% of GDP CIM, ignoring the second order economic effects from the things that you've listed that would impact the wider economy.


RE: John Healey resigns - Protheroe - 06-11-2026

(06-11-2026, 12:48 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Oh dear
Another hefty kick in the nether regions for the bloke who isn't very good at politics.

I wonder what Bodybags will say? 

He needs to say something on this. Though whether he means it is another thing entirely.

(06-11-2026, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You're halfway to getting to 3% of GDP CIM, ignoring the second order economic effects from the things that you've listed that would impact the wider economy.

If you want to spend any more on anything without additional borrowing (good luck with that), 2.5%+ annual growth (arf) or additional taxation (can't raise any more) then the only game in town is welfare cuts.

The welfare budget is wholly unsustainable as it is. We all agree on that.

We need to tell people with mild forms of anxiety and depression that they can get treatment, but not benefits - as we all also know that work is generally very good for mental health.

We also need to stop paying PIP for mild childhood diagnoses too.

And the triple lock needs to go now.


RE: John Healey resigns - Borin' Baggie - 06-11-2026

I fail to see how that would have anywhere near a substantial impact on welfare spending.