WBAUnofficial
Gary's Economics - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Gary's Economics (/showthread.php?tid=42041)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-09-2026

I mentioned this on another thread, but I suggest everyone takes a look at this.

https://www.channel4.com/programmes/how-to-get-filthy-rich-with-gary-stevenson/on-demand/78427-001

I'm pretty sure it wasn't his intention, but I think it exposes Gary for the grifter that he is. Especially when he's exposed to challenge by an actual expert Dan Niedle.

As ever, there are no simple solutions for complex problems. Gary doesn't even mention the lack of housebuilding for 50 years, nor the distortions to wealth distribution brought about by a decade and a half of zero real interest rates.

Nor is he able to explain how a simple Wealth Tax could be collected, on what basis assets would be valued and how it would translate into any improvement in life chances for those he purports to represent.


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-09-2026

Grifters are only Grifters if they are saying something that you don't want to hear Proth, you should know that by now.


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-09-2026

Arf. Of course.

But I love the fact that he believes a wholly ill defined tax on the wealthy will magically cascade into wealth for the not so wealthy. It’s primary school stuff.


RE: Gary's Economics - Hughie Reed 31 - 07-09-2026

(07-09-2026, 03:40 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Arf. Of course.

But I love the fact that he believes a wholly ill defined tax on the wealthy will magically cascade into wealth for the not so wealthy. It’s primary school stuff.

I don’t think he factored in that all the rich guys will fuck off somewhere else


RE: Gary's Economics - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 07-09-2026

I filmed an interview with him last year, fascinating guy. I’m not sure you can accuse him of being a grifter for wanting change for the greater good.


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-09-2026

Peddling economically illiterate false hope to poor people is the definition of grifting.


RE: Gary's Economics - Shabby Russian - 07-10-2026

(07-09-2026, 09:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Peddling economically illiterate false hope to poor people is the definition of grifting.

Got to admire your chutzpah, in describing someone with a philosophy in economics from Oxford Uni as peddling economically illiterate false hope, especially when you take on board that he funded the course from betting on the under performance of the UK economy controlled by a Govt you campaigned and advocated for..

Chapeau.


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026

I'm yet to hear a reasoned explanation of how his wealth tax would work. In theory it is a decent idea, but the practicalities of how to measure 'wealth', the collection of that tax, and what the actual amount that it would bring in have not been explained very well.

I have no doubt that he is well meaning and also well qualified to speak on the subject, but so is Dan Neidle who is an expert, remember them, in tax affairs and the legislating of, and the litigation around, said taxes.

Can anyone enlighten me?


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-10-2026

(07-10-2026, 08:30 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-09-2026, 09:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Peddling economically illiterate false hope to poor people is the definition of grifting.

Got to admire your chutzpah, in describing someone with a philosophy in economics from Oxford Uni as peddling economically illiterate false hope, especially when you take on board that he funded the course from betting on the under performance of the UK economy controlled by a Govt you campaigned and advocated for..

Chapeau.

Gary didn't "bet" on the under performance of the UK economy or more accurately he didn't bet that "inequality would get worse" (his words). He bet on asset prices rising. That isn't "betting" it's a simple long trade. As Dan Neidle says ""Assets go up" isn't just a bet on inequality. It's a bet that pays out if you're right about demographics, or China, or a mad bubble, or QE, or nothing at all. The market can't tell you which one you were right about. It only tells you that you were right."

He never really defines "inequality" beyond simple populist rhetoric; Between 1980 and 2019, the share of wealth owned by the richest 1 per cent grew by 12% in the US, compared to a rise of less than 1% in the UK. Does that scream "inequality getting worse"? Well, maybe marginally so. But the inequality issue is not just about wealth, it's about age distribution - which Gary NEVER talks about except when telling us his mum and dad bought a house really cheap in Ilford.

It doesn't it take a genius to conclude that if you suppress interest rates for 15 years (something I consistently argued against), that might encourage the already wealthy (and older) to borrow at negative real interest rates. I did. In fact, it's a guaranteed outcome. But rapidly increasing inequality? The evidence doesn't support that.

Gary seems to believe that high net worths are hoarding property and making a killing on it, yet when challenged that the real capital returns on property over the last decade are DOWN 9% nationally and 17% in London he tends to change the subject.

Gary has never explained how a 2% annual Wealth Tax will work in the UK when all the research carried out by far more eminent economists than him suggests that it won't. Please take a look at that work and let me know what you disagree with: https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2025/07/22/uk-wealth-tax-anti-growth/

He has stated, including in that risible documentary that a Wealth Tax will mean poorer Brits will be able to own "more homes, shares and pensions". Does anyone have the first clue what he means by this? And how it's a direct correlation? Does he mean investors will dump assets and capital will take flight and we can all pick stuff up cheaply? Isn't that an ever so slightly problematic sceanrio?

I'm sure Gary's motivation is virtuous, but he's hopelessly wrong on the distributional effects of such a policy and the effect on behaviour of investors. It won't be just the super-rich that pull the oars in, it will be everyone - because as everyone knows taxes on the wealthy or those on high incomes are the thin end of a very thick wedge. Just consider the heavy lifting that fiscal drag is doing today for people on middle incomes and the negative behavioural effects that encourages. I don't make this shit up you know - you can actually see the evidence with your own eyes.

I'm pretty certain that this documentary sounded like a good idea when Gary was considering it from behind his kitchen table. But his onanist pontifications don't survive contact with the the scrutiny of actual experts or contact with reality do they?

If I was you I'd follow Labour-member Dan Neidle instead. Of course I won't agree with the broad thrust of his progressive agenda on taxation, but at least he knows what he's talking about when it comes down to policy cause and effect. Gary Stevenson doesn't even have a basic grasp of facts, let alone incentives and behaviour.


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026

Although Grifter is probably a bit harsh, it doesn't change the fact that he is promoting a simple solution, Tax the Wealthy, without any real substance to it. Stop the Boats, Get Brexit Done, Tax the Wealthy, Drain the Swamp - all slogans that people can go 'yeah, that sounds like the right thing to do' to, but scratch beneath the surface and there is no information that is based in reality.