WBAUnofficial
Has it worked? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Has it worked? (/showthread.php?tid=42905)

Pages: 1 2 3


Has it worked? - Derek Hardballs - 09-30-2026

After 50 years of been told that deregulation, privatisation, denationalisation and Brexit were the right way to go by the likes of Thatcher, Johnson, The Mail, Telegraph etc the question is… 

Has it worked? 

I’m just off now to work out if I can afford a to eat, heat the house or fill the car up.


RE: Has it worked? - baggy1 - 09-30-2026

(09-30-2026, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: After 50 years of been told that deregulation, privatisation, denationalisation and Brexit were the right way to go by the likes of Thatcher, Johnson, The Mail, Telegraph etc the question is… 

Has it worked? 

I’m just off now to work out if I can afford a to eat, heat the house or fill the car up.

You could go back 50 years and live in a house with ice on the inside of the windows, get the bus to work, and grow a lot of your own food in the garden. If you genuinly think we are worse off than 50 years ago then you need to update you algorithm. The 70s and 80s were great to live in as a kid, but strikes, blackouts, three TV channels and one car family for the middle class families, were the norm.

Some privatisation should never have happened, water and rail being the obvious ones. However privatising telecoms and allowing completion has definitely been a success.


RE: Has it worked? - Borin' Baggie - 09-30-2026

Privatisation of entities like BL, BAE, BA etc that have market competition has worked.

Privatisation of infrastructure investment (CEGB, Water, what is now Network Rail etc.) has not worked and is a substantial cause of current infrastructure issues.

The London Review of Books had a very good article this week speaking about the completely failed sell off of the energy sector that failed to liberalise the energy markets to enable private investment while undermining state investment meaning there was no investment.


RE: Has it worked? - Derek Hardballs - 09-30-2026

(09-30-2026, 09:47 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-30-2026, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: After 50 years of been told that deregulation, privatisation, denationalisation and Brexit were the right way to go by the likes of Thatcher, Johnson, The Mail, Telegraph etc the question is… 

Has it worked? 

I’m just off now to work out if I can afford a to eat, heat the house or fill the car up.

You could go back 50 years and live in a house with ice on the inside of the windows, get the bus to work, and grow a lot of your own food in the garden. If you genuinly think we are worse off than 50 years ago then you need to update you algorithm. The 70s and 80s were great to live in as a kid, but strikes, blackouts, three TV channels and one car family for the middle class families, were the norm.

Some privatisation should never have happened, water and rail being the obvious ones. However privatising telecoms and allowing completion has definitely been a success.

B1 being a condescending twonk shocker. I put up a post and you immediately reply with some dullard response about algorithms. I only use Instagram and completely unrelated to politics. 

Jumping to the defence of Thatcherism which is really what the last 50 years has been, is an interesting position to take.


RE: Has it worked? - Tom Joad 25 - 09-30-2026

(09-30-2026, 09:47 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-30-2026, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: After 50 years of been told that deregulation, privatisation, denationalisation and Brexit were the right way to go by the likes of Thatcher, Johnson, The Mail, Telegraph etc the question is… 

Has it worked? 

I’m just off now to work out if I can afford a to eat, heat the house or fill the car up.

You could go back 50 years and live in a house with ice on the inside of the windows, get the bus to work, and grow a lot of your own food in the garden. If you genuinly think we are worse off than 50 years ago then you need to update you algorithm. The 70s and 80s were great to live in as a kid, but strikes, blackouts, three TV channels and one car family for the middle class families, were the norm.

Some privatisation should never have happened, water and rail being the obvious ones. However privatising telecoms and allowing completion has definitely been a success.

No. It absolutely definitely has not worked for the better of most. The strikes, blackouts nonsense is one of those perpetual sticks with which to beat those that point out Thatcherism has destroyed the idea of society. Let's go the whole hog. Send our grandkids up chimneys, put our daughters into service, doff our caps when our betters pass by.
Ice on the windows, getting a bus, growing your own food? No big deal. Having no police, no housing, no services, can't afford electricity or gas, courts blocked, jails too full to hold any more criminals, needing both partners to work full time to rent a house, zero hours contracts, homeless and beggars everywhere.  That's living, eh?
I left school early 70s, make no mistake it was great, life was full of hope.


RE: Has it worked? - baggy1 - 09-30-2026

So just so we’re clear here, both BB and myself answered with the same sentiment and you both have decided to have a go at me. Tom the question wasn’t has Thatcherism worked it was has privatisation worked and the answer is yes in some cases and no in others.


RE: Has it worked? - Protheroe - 09-30-2026

(09-30-2026, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: After 50 years of been told that deregulation, privatisation, denationalisation and Brexit were the right way to go by the likes of Thatcher, Johnson, The Mail, Telegraph etc the question is… 

Has it worked? 

Have you been listening to James O'Brien again Dekka?

In large parts yes, very much so. In some parts no, not at all.

The sale of ABP, BA, BP, BAA, BT, BAE, Rolls Royce has netted huge inflows to the Treasury reversing previous outflows. Even British Steel was paying huge corporation tax revenues until a combination of foreign competition and latterly energy prices and net zero hamstrung it.

I would have liked Burnham to have spoken about crony-capitalism where the state has been in bed with businesses one way or another during those 50 years. The most striking being Banking. The UK government had a once in a generation opportunity to reform banking and introduce real competition - instead we managed to nationalise private debt and actually reduce competition in the sector. But his hero Gordon Brown started that which is maybe why he stayed quiet.

The UK did not deregulate planning, which has given us the housing crisis.

I don't think it's even a debate to point to the regulatory failure of both the financing and performance of the water sector.

The energy sector is more nuanced. I doubt many us gave it a second thought before the invasion of Ukraine, but now we are severely lacking in gas storage and have a grid which is years behind the development of renewables. 
  
As a child of the 1970s I don't recall that being a golden era.  I do recall my dad being on strike all the time, power cuts, tinned fruit cocktail being a treat, no car, black and white rented telly, twin tub, fridge with just an ice box and the grinding poverty some of my friends on Chelmsley lived in.


RE: Has it worked? - Borin' Baggie - 09-30-2026

How is the energy sector more nuanced? We knew we needed to build out a new nuclear fleet in the 1970s (which France did), we knew we needed to replace the strategic gas storage lost from the coal gas holders and the government were told not to close Rough (they ignored that), we knew by the early 2000s that the grid needed massive expansion (which is why RIIO became a thing before Russia invaded Ukraine), we knew we needed to electrifify heat (which the Nordics, Finland and Baltics did). The fact is that privatising CEGB has made that functionally impossible, the government are banned by the 1989 Electricity Act to borrow to invest directly in energy infrastructure, that's why CfDs and the Capacity Market fudges came in. And why Centrica owned strategic gas storage and EDF nuclear power is beyond me, it's one thing to privatise coal and gas generators but strategic resources and uneconomical but critical generators? The notion that the UK and Germany couldn't foresee the issues that have arisen when other countries did is ludicrous.

The Thatcher government post-1981 (and subsequent, excluding Brown and the coalition) approach to energy was insane compared with the Callaghan government approach and the mistakes of the Thatcher government resulted in so many lost skills and barriers. I've said it before but I'll say it again, Lawson was the worst energy minister we've ever had.


RE: Has it worked? - Fido - 09-30-2026

There some patient and coherent replies to what was, in essence, Derek just waking up this morning and deciding he had to have an unsubstantiated rant about something.


RE: Has it worked? - Shabby Russian - 09-30-2026

(09-30-2026, 01:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So just so we’re clear here, both BB and myself answered with the same sentiment and you both have decided to have a go at me. Tom the question wasn’t has Thatcherism worked it was has privatisation worked and the answer is yes in some cases and no in others.

Your first paragraph was very different from BB's point, which was narrow but correct. You widened the debate (not a bad thing) to a much more widespread discussion on the value of the changes from 1970 to the present day.

There is always a danger that old codgers like me can see a decade like the 70s through the rose tinted glasses of nostalgia.  But i feel less optimistic about the future today, than i did in 1979. i worry my children are going to have to face far more serious, almost existentsial , challenges in the next 50 years, than we have had to contend with in the last 50 years.