This Bus Fare Price Cap
#21
(07-23-2026, 08:13 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 09:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I guess you never used British Rail.

Of course I did, it was far from perfect as it suffered from the same under investment that all the nationalised companies suffered from. But it is certainly worse now.  I wonder how much actual experience you had of those pre privatisation days? Or do you just repeat the mantras of the old blue rinse brigade. From water to energy, transport to telecoms and housing to society in general, Thatcher fucked it all up. A pattern her pale imitation successors have continued feebly since.

Tom, my experience mirrors your own: I was a regular traveller by train both before and after privatisation; taken in the round I would say the experiences were similar - patchy; some very good, some less so. There has certainly been nothing transformative about the experience post carve-up.

The supposed benefits to taxpayers and passengers never materialised: over the final years of BR aggregate subsidies were falling steadily, then rapidly, undoubtedly a deliberate strategy; by the time of privatisation they had more than halved between 1992 and ’94 and thereafter tapered down further. They didn’t stay low for long…

From 2000 onwards taxpayer money had to be poured into the system for a number of reasons, a lot of it down to infrastructure failure and sometimes negligence. Following Southall (97) and then Ladbroke Grove (99) the Hatfield disaster in 2000 was, finally, the last straw and infrastructure was eventually taken back into public ownership. Since 2002 (Potters Bar) there have been 4 fatalities nominally as a consequence of infrastructure issues, with 3 of them being caused by the Stonehaven landslip in 2022; none since. This is broadly in line with what we had come to expect in BR days, aside from aberrations like Clapham in the late 80s.

By 2020 annual subsidies had climbed to around £10 billion, spiked further during Covid (so we’ll disregard that), and have settled back at around £12 billion according to the most recent data. So who’s benefitted? Apparently not the taxpayer…

Not the fare-paying passenger either, in most years post-privatisation. Prior to the current freeze there have consistently been above inflation increases in all but a couple of years (I think it is literally a couple). 

This is worth a read…

https://granta.com/the-1210-to-leeds/
Reply
#22
Shifting debt onto firms to pay dividends is regulatory failure Dekka. Thames Water shareholders for instance ought to be wiped out, just like shareholders in failed banks ought to have been wiped out.
Reply
#23
(07-23-2026, 03:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Shifting debt onto firms to pay dividends is regulatory failure Dekka. Thames Water shareholders for instance ought to be wiped out, just like shareholders in failed banks ought to have been wiped out.

But you are selective where you point your finger. In the case of the water companies the private companies themselves inveigled themselves with the regulator. The fact remains, privatisation has made us all poorer, both financially and as a society. This is down to the Conservatives.
Reply
#24
(07-23-2026, 07:10 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(07-23-2026, 03:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Shifting debt onto firms to pay dividends is regulatory failure Dekka. Thames Water shareholders for instance ought to be wiped out, just like shareholders in failed banks ought to have been wiped out.

But you are selective where you point your finger. In the case of the water companies the private companies themselves inveigled themselves with the regulator. The fact remains, privatisation has made us all poorer, both financially and as a society. This is down to the Conservatives.

It's a lot more complex than that - particularly given the age, condition and nature of our combined sewer infrastructure.  Labour had 13 years to reverse this and chose not to - most probably baulking at the likely cost of investment. Likewise Burnham also knows that regulation is likely the only game in town in far more straitened economic times. Do you want to be poorer because of privatisation, or poorer due to tax and borrowing for infrastructure investment?
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/...-of-review

Water, like transport and dare I say hospices is just another area competing for support.
Reply
#25
(07-23-2026, 08:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-23-2026, 07:10 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(07-23-2026, 03:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Shifting debt onto firms to pay dividends is regulatory failure Dekka. Thames Water shareholders for instance ought to be wiped out, just like shareholders in failed banks ought to have been wiped out.

But you are selective where you point your finger. In the case of the water companies the private companies themselves inveigled themselves with the regulator. The fact remains, privatisation has made us all poorer, both financially and as a society. This is down to the Conservatives.

It's a lot more complex than that - particularly given the age, condition and nature of our combined sewer infrastructure.  Labour had 13 years to reverse this and chose not to - most probably baulking at the likely cost of investment. Likewise Burnham also knows that regulation is likely the only game in town in far more straitened economic times. Do you want to be poorer because of privatisation, or poorer due to tax and borrowing for infrastructure investment?
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/...-of-review

Water, like transport and dare I say hospices is just another area competing for support.

Jeez, I simply expect a modern country to have a functioning water supply. No amount of whataboutery deflects from the fact your party initiated a terrible mess, regardless of how much you need to convince yourself and others.
Reply
#26
I’m not sure Paddocks insights have quite reached the upper chamber
Raw Sausage
Reply
#27
(07-24-2026, 06:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Jeez, I simply expect a modern country to have a functioning water supply. No amount of whataboutery deflects from the fact your party initiated a terrible mess, regardless of how much you need to convince yourself and others.

So do I. It's not whataboutery to point out what that will cost. Unfortunately you're just another guy in search of simple solutions in a complex world.
Reply
#28
(07-24-2026, 07:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-24-2026, 06:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Jeez, I simply expect a modern country to have a functioning water supply. No amount of whataboutery deflects from the fact your party initiated a terrible mess, regardless of how much you need to convince yourself and others.

So do I. It's not whataboutery to point out what that will cost. Unfortunately you're just another guy in search of simple solutions in a complex world.

Not at all. I've just pointed out that paying shareholder dividends is no replacement for proper investment. That part actually is quite simple.
Reply
#29
(07-24-2026, 08:54 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(07-24-2026, 07:35 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-24-2026, 06:46 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Jeez, I simply expect a modern country to have a functioning water supply. No amount of whataboutery deflects from the fact your party initiated a terrible mess, regardless of how much you need to convince yourself and others.

So do I. It's not whataboutery to point out what that will cost. Unfortunately you're just another guy in search of simple solutions in a complex world.

Not at all. I've just pointed out that paying shareholder dividends is no replacement for proper investment. That part actually is quite simple.

And I agree with you, when those dividends are derived from loading the company with debt for that very purpose.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)