Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(11-17-2026, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (11-16-2026, 07:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-14-2026, 09:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (11-13-2026, 04:36 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-13-2026, 01:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So you do support it. Abdicating any responsibility by developers as usual from decisions they could make for the good of all concerned not just themselves and their profits.
What is there to support? Wigan Council allocates a site through the strategic planning process for industrial development, applicant applies and rightly gets consent on an allocated site.
You are going to have to point out to me where the problem is the developer.
NB - If Wigan had not given consent then the developer would have won summarily on appeal, at a cost to Wigan taxpayers.
Peel do not get absolved from this Proth, despite Wigan's incompetence they are the ones who changed the sizes of the proposed warehouse after their initial application lapsed in the reapplication and they're the ones who signed off and are responsible for plans that erode privacy and have created flooding issues.
I suspect it's the contractor, engineer and the PM who've conspired to to create flooding issues. Can you explain how a big shed erodes privacy?
Peel are uniquely absolved from their obligations and responsibilities as the client under CDM are they?
And how does putting a giant warehouse three times taller than the initial lapsed plans with security systems and sight lines peering into people's gardens and into a primary school erode privacy? Seriously? Have you see the thing that's been built?
I've built several similar. Please don't try to lecture me about the practicalities and dynamics of development - I've had to resolve issues with my own consultants & contractors when these sort of issues have "arisen".
There are no privacy issues that cannot be dealt with between the local authority and the developer / investor. Again, I've dealt with them myself.
Tbh if you don't want big sheds then stop buying stuff online. Everyone neighbouring that site will use Amazon. Go figure. More NIMBY bollocks - you bought a house next to site with an existing industrial allocation. Caveat emptor.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
You've built several similar 18m tall warehouses backing up directly onto primary schools and people's gardens and it's never once occurred to you that this has serious issues? The pictures are right there, as are the videos and images of workers peering into people's gardens, having CCTV pointed directly into their gardens with zero screening provisions and having their properties damaged with water run off and none of it has been fixed, are you seriously trying to argue that Peel, the fucking client and landowner, have no responsibility?
And when they bought the house the existing warehouse plans were significantly scaled back compared to what was approved in 2024 which was submitted after the houses were built which Peel knew because they were also the responsible developer for the bloody housing.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I built several million square feet of high-bay warehouses before the GFC.
One of the sites was a greenfield allocation like this, where the developable area was 80 acres out of 300 for about 1.5m sq ft net creating about 3,500 new jobs. The planning authority (Tory) insisted on huge landscaping works, prescriptive drainage - land drains, swales, balancing ponds etc. There were big s106 payments and a massive s278 payment for dualling an A-road with a new junction into the site. We created a Forest School for the local primary school in one of the wooded areas.
The Council's drainage plans weren't good enough so we had to spend more money on remediation after the first phase of development. Our security and CCTV was designed specifically to the local authority specs to avoid overlooking the large local authority estate adjacent to the site.
In Wigan, the run-off issue needs to be sorted by the developer under the watch of the Council's engineer. The CCTV needs to be sorted too. Neither of these issues amount to a hill of beans.
In building these sheds Peel has responded to the market created by you, me and everyone else who buys online. The market changed massively during and after Covid, high bay sheds were and still are in great demand with little supply. Wigan wanted the investment and the jobs, so gave consent for development on a site it had allocated knowing that Peel would win on appeal if it refused consent.
That the folk who live in houses next to a previously allocated industrial site don't like the aesthetic of an aircraft hanger next to them is an issue they needed to take up with the Council long ago. Or perhaps not to have bought a house next to an undeveloped allocated industrial site.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
11-17-2026, 02:18 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-17-2026, 02:28 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
The folk who live there bought their houses when the submitted plans were significantly scaled back to what was submitted in 2024 and built and the issues with privacy, screening and flooding have not been addressed with Peel dragging their feet, on top of Whistl pursuing 24-hour logistic operations. Address the point. And the council being incompetent and negilgent does not in any way absolve the developer from responsibility, that is not an excuse.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
11-17-2026, 02:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-17-2026, 02:38 PM by Protheroe.)
BB. In my experience, which it's fair to say in this area is far far greater than yours - residents will object to ANYTHING being built next to them, whether it's offices, houses, small industrial units, a hospital, school or big sheds.
There is nothing particularly unusual about this development or the neighbours' response to it.
Would I have bought a house next to an unimplemented industrial land allocation? No.
I'm not entirely sure where the Council has been "negligent" either. The reserved matters look fairly standard.
https://democracy.wigan.gov.uk/documents...f?T=10&a=1
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
I have worked on multiple medium and large energy infrastructure projects, I have worked on the largest rail project in Europe. You are not the only person with experience on public response to developments here.
The people that bought those houses do not have magic crystal balls, how the hell were supposed to know that Peel would let the low-rise development that had planning permission when they bought the houses lapse to be replaced with a development a third to two thirds taller exactly?
And a council rushing through revised plans to grant consents without properly scrutinising the changes is negligent especially given people were already living there and a primary school was fully operational when the plans that were built were approved. Compounded with their behaviour to grant a 24-hour operational licence to Whistl in 2026, have you followed or looked into this at all?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(11-17-2026, 03:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I have worked on multiple medium and large energy infrastructure projects, I have worked on the largest rail project in Europe. You are not the only person with experience on public response to developments here.
The people that bought those houses do not have magic crystal balls, how the hell were supposed to know that Peel would let the low-rise development that had planning permission when they bought the houses lapse to be replaced with a development a third to two thirds taller exactly?
And a council rushing through revised plans to grant consents without properly scrutinising the changes is negligent especially given people were already living there and a primary school was fully operational when the plans that were built were approved. Compounded with their behaviour to grant a 24-hour operational licence to Whistl in 2026, have you followed or looked into this at all?
We're talking about sheds, on a previously allocated site. That site will have gone through a huge consultation in the Strategic Planning process one or two decades ago. It's not comparable with what you have worked on at all because the decision IN PRINCIPLE was already made.
You don't need a crystal ball to read LA Searches. Perhaps the residents should've considered what their conveyancers sent to them. Perhaps the conveyancers should've advised better.
As for the planners 18m is not that tall in high-bay terms, we were regularly building higher twenty years ago - and the tallest are over 40m these days. 140,000 sq ft is not that big in modern terms - that was on the low side for jobs I worked on. What more scrutiny do you want for an allocated industrial site where the decision in principle has already been made?
As it is the Traffic Commissioner has imposed an interim Midnight - 6:00AM restriction (it's not in the Council's gift to grant an operating licence) which will in all likelihood be made permanent. The Council can also continue to monitor noise to ensure compliance and sort the drainage issues (really minor stuff that).
When you buy a house you do not buy the view and you do not guarantee 24 hour peace and quiet. Especially when you buy a house next to an allocated industrial site.
Posts: 17,070
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
11-17-2026, 05:55 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-17-2026, 06:21 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(11-17-2026, 05:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-17-2026, 03:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I have worked on multiple medium and large energy infrastructure projects, I have worked on the largest rail project in Europe. You are not the only person with experience on public response to developments here.
The people that bought those houses do not have magic crystal balls, how the hell were supposed to know that Peel would let the low-rise development that had planning permission when they bought the houses lapse to be replaced with a development a third to two thirds taller exactly?
And a council rushing through revised plans to grant consents without properly scrutinising the changes is negligent especially given people were already living there and a primary school was fully operational when the plans that were built were approved. Compounded with their behaviour to grant a 24-hour operational licence to Whistl in 2026, have you followed or looked into this at all?
We're talking about sheds, on a previously allocated site. That site will have gone through a huge consultation in the Strategic Planning process one or two decades ago. It's not comparable with what you have worked on at all because the decision IN PRINCIPLE was already made.
You don't need a crystal ball to read LA Searches. Perhaps the residents should've considered what their conveyancers sent to them. Perhaps the conveyancers should've advised better.
As for the planners 18m is not that tall in high-bay terms, we were regularly building higher twenty years ago - and the tallest are over 40m these days. 140,000 sq ft is not that big in modern terms - that was on the low side for jobs I worked on. What more scrutiny do you want for an allocated industrial site where the decision in principle has already been made?
As it is the Traffic Commissioner has imposed an interim Midnight - 6:00AM restriction (it's not in the Council's gift to grant an operating licence) which will in all likelihood be made permanent. The Council can also continue to monitor noise to ensure compliance and sort the drainage issues (really minor stuff that).
When you buy a house you do not buy the view and you do not guarantee 24 hour peace and quiet. Especially when you buy a house next to an allocated industrial site.
…and that ladies and gentlemen is why you can never trust a developer in this country. Absolutely no desire to do what’s right, no empathy whatsoever and only cares about profit.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(11-17-2026, 05:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-17-2026, 03:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I have worked on multiple medium and large energy infrastructure projects, I have worked on the largest rail project in Europe. You are not the only person with experience on public response to developments here.
The people that bought those houses do not have magic crystal balls, how the hell were supposed to know that Peel would let the low-rise development that had planning permission when they bought the houses lapse to be replaced with a development a third to two thirds taller exactly?
And a council rushing through revised plans to grant consents without properly scrutinising the changes is negligent especially given people were already living there and a primary school was fully operational when the plans that were built were approved. Compounded with their behaviour to grant a 24-hour operational licence to Whistl in 2026, have you followed or looked into this at all?
We're talking about sheds, on a previously allocated site. That site will have gone through a huge consultation in the Strategic Planning process one or two decades ago. It's not comparable with what you have worked on at all because the decision IN PRINCIPLE was already made.
You don't need a crystal ball to read LA Searches. Perhaps the residents should've considered what their conveyancers sent to them. Perhaps the conveyancers should've advised better.
As for the planners 18m is not that tall in high-bay terms, we were regularly building higher twenty years ago - and the tallest are over 40m these days. 140,000 sq ft is not that big in modern terms - that was on the low side for jobs I worked on. What more scrutiny do you want for an allocated industrial site where the decision in principle has already been made?
As it is the Traffic Commissioner has imposed an interim Midnight - 6:00AM restriction (it's not in the Council's gift to grant an operating licence) which will in all likelihood be made permanent. The Council can also continue to monitor noise to ensure compliance and sort the drainage issues (really minor stuff that).
When you buy a house you do not buy the view and you do not guarantee 24 hour peace and quiet. Especially when you buy a house next to an allocated industrial site.
For fucks sakes, stop talking over me and ignoring everything I have written while making false assumptions. I have worked with developers in strategic allocation zones, I have worked on projects within SDSs in London and are being rolled out nationwide and I've even worked with WSP on lands and consents for energy projects. I know what was allocated for this land, I have clearly been following it for significantly longer than you. I know about the mixed-use industrial/housing plan that was set forward. I know about the initial outline planning permission proposal. I know how this works, this isn't new information. You are deliberately ignoring the fact that the initial outline planning application and the initial full planning application were for warehouses on that site that are significantly shallower than what was built, all of those houses were built and sold well prior to the 18m second full application going in to Wigan council in 2024. So yes, they did need a fucking crystal ball. And that's not even mentioning the houses and primary school directly adjacent to the western edge of the development which were there well before the outline planning submission in 2006.
So what scrutiny? Maybe the fact that in the time between that land being earmarked for shallower warehouses and the full planning application going in to Wigan in 2024 for 18m tall warehouses there was a housing development built adjacent to the site warranting significantly more scrutiny as the conditions had changed? The fact that outline planning and full planning had been previously granted for shallower warehouses and that should be kept to? Seems pretty obvious to me.
And the Traffic Commissioner had imposed those temporary restrictions last week, the warehouses have been in-use since July. There were no conditions or restrictions on the land being used adjacent to a residential development 24/7 by Wigan council, we both know full well that councils have the power to impose said conditions and regularly use said powers as part of granting planning permission up and down the country.
As for 18m not being that tall, do you never bother to look at context when devising development plans? 18m might be small in a well screened logistics park well clear of any residential areas but it's a bit different when it's adjacent to housing and things like screening, landscaping and earthworks to mitigate that are extremely important especially when there are limitations to screening because of gas mains routing like at Astley. I wouldn't go around arguing we should put 1.5GW gas turbine adjacent to a housing development to balance urban demand loads 1.5GW is middling for a gas turbine, it wouldn't make any sense.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I’m ignoring much of what you say because it’s irrelevant. Yes, the development is out of scale - boo hoo, yes it’s a bit noisy, so the TC has put a restriction on. But it’s an allocated industrial site. Would they have preferred a lower foundry or a lower rendering plant? A squat abattoir or an MDR facility?
|