Left Wing politics at its most juvenile
#41
Anyway, back to the OP. How about those nasty Greens? Who'd have thought allowing entryists into the party would breed rampant extremism. That hasn't happened under a populist left wing leader before has it? Oh....
Reply
#42
If the reservations for West Germany were not used, which they weren't, then they were not applicable. This is like saying Canada wasn't functionally independent after 1931. West Germany was not occupied after 1952 outside of the Saarland, civil control was based in the Bonn government and not London, Paris and DC.

The PA was not transitioned into power in Gaza, it wasn't even warned of the withdrawal. Being told one day without warning that Israel was retreating from Gaza tomorrow, here's the keys, good luck is not a transition. There is no capacity to build up institutions and establish civil control there, that is why there was a power vacuum.

Someone's clutching at straws here but it's not me. You can't hide behind legal frameworks to distract from what actually happened.
Reply
#43
(10-06-2026, 11:33 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If the reservations for West Germany were not used, which they weren't, then they were not applicable. This is like saying Canada wasn't functionally independent after 1931. West Germany was not occupied after 1952 outside of the Saarland, civil control was based in the Bonn government and not London, Paris and DC.

The PA was not transitioned into power in Gaza, it wasn't even warned of the withdrawal. Being told one day without warning that Israel was retreating from Gaza tomorrow, here's the keys, good luck is not a transition. There is no capacity to build up institutions and establish civil control there, that is why there was a power vacuum.

Someone's clutching at straws here but it's not me. You can't hide behind legal frameworks to distract from what actually happened.

So no response to your false equivalence and fantasy then, after accusing me of the same? Thought not, just more obfuscation.

Where to start?

Saying reserved Allied rights "were never used" is factually wrong, the latest in a long line of mistruths you've presented as facts during our debate, there are more to come too. The Allies used their reserved powers continuously up until the 1968 Emergency Acts, even after this they retained supreme legal authority over West Berlin until 1990, and maintained military jurisdiction over all foreign troop deployments in West Germany (doesn't sound like any sovereign country I know). Your Strawman comparing a defeated, four-power occupied state to Canada voluntarily transitioning out of the British Empire via the 1931 Statute of Westminster is another absurd false equivalence.

To your second point, claiming the PA was given "no warning" on Gaza is a complete rewrite of reality ffs.

The Knesset passed the Disengagement Law in February 2005. The actual withdrawal didn't happen until August 2005. The PA had six months of explicit advanced notice of the withdrawal, moreover, Sharon first announced their intention to withdraw in December 2003, that's 20 months lead-in time for the PA to prepare; there were international coordination and cooperation efforts led by James Wolfensohn on getting agricultural infrastructure directly into PA control, this was clearly not a case of here are the keys good luck, as you seem to want to paint it.

More importantly, Hamas didn't seize Gaza "tomorrow" in 2005, they ousted the PA in June 2007, two full years later. The PA had the best part of 2 years, tens of thousands of security personnel, and international financial backing to govern Gaza. Again, they didn't lose Gaza because of a "lack of warning" they lost it because Hamas routed them in less than a week in a civil war.

If two years, international funding, and thousands of armed guards weren't enough time for the PA to maintain control against well-armed and motivated extremists, a 'negotiated transition' on a piece of paper won't save them in the West Bank either. You'll hit bedrock soon.
Reply
#44
Who passed the German Emergency Acts, which Civillian Authority amended the German constitution? Pretty sure it wasn't the Allies. Did you bother to look up the Deutschlandvertrag when West German sovereignty and independence was formally established and accepted by the allies, which is why I referred to 1952? Reserved powers were not used by the allies in West Germany beyond that date. And I brought up Canada because it was functionally independent and sovereign after 1931, not 1982 when reserved powers that Westminster held but were never used were removed. And you have decided to assert that control over foreign troop movements under NATO command implies occupation ergo making that implication again.

And 6 months to form power structures with no transitional support to enforce control is not a transition. The PA being overthrown didn't happen overnight, did it? South Africa took four years to transition out of Apartheid, Eastern Croatia took 3 years and both of those had a formal transition of power to establish democratic legitimatacy.
Reply
#45
Every day is a schoolday isn't it?

However, what on Earth any of this has to do with the establishment of a viable Palestinian State is beyond me. It seems the illegitimate PA alone is interested in a two-state solution; none of the other political or paramilitary groups do - and Palestinians certainly don't seem too keen either if the polling is to be believed. I doubt those who back the Palestinians with arms and cash want a long term viable solution either. This is nothing like any other situation.

If that's the case why of Earth do you think the imposition of something so unwanted will be greeted with anything other than more conflict? Which was the point I made in the first place?
Reply
#46
(10-06-2026, 01:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Every day is a schoolday isn't it?

However, what on Earth any of this has to do with the establishment of a viable Palestinian State is beyond me. It seems the illegitimate PA alone is interested in a two-state solution; none of the other political or paramilitary groups do - and Palestinians certainly don't seem too keen either if the polling is to be believed. I doubt those who back the Palestinians with arms and cash want a long term viable solution either. This is nothing like any other situation.

If that's the case why of Earth do you think the imposition of something so unwanted will be greeted with anything other than more conflict? Which was the point I made in the first place?

https://www.foreignaffairs.com/palestini...aney-jamal

You're basing that opinion on one article from a Think Tank and ignoring both historical polling from PCPSR and recent polling.

The fundamental issue at present blocking any sort of plan from forming is that outside the brief period when Lapid was PM the Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.
Reply
#47
(10-06-2026, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Who passed the German Emergency Acts, which Civillian Authority amended the German constitution? Pretty sure it wasn't the Allies. Did you bother to look up the Deutschlandvertrag when West German sovereignty and independence was formally established and accepted by the allies, which is why I referred to 1952? Reserved powers were not used by the allies in West Germany beyond that date. And I brought up Canada because it was functionally independent and sovereign after 1931, not 1982 when reserved powers that Westminster held but were never used were removed. And you have decided to assert that control over foreign troop movements under NATO command implies occupation ergo making that implication again.

And 6 months to form power structures with no transitional support to enforce control is not a transition. The PA being overthrown didn't happen overnight, did it? South Africa took four years to transition out of Apartheid, Eastern Croatia took 3 years and both of those had a formal transition of power to establish democratic legitimatacy.

Who passed the Emergency Acts? West Germany, they were forced to pass them because the Allies held reserved powers over them. The Deutschlandvertrag explicitly stated in Article 5 that Allied reserved intervention powers would remain active until West Germany passed internal emergency laws satisfactory to the Allies. Passing those acts was the literal price the Allies demanded to relinquish that specific piece of occupation authority, it took Bonn 23 years to comply.

You like a question, so here's mine, if West Germany became fully sovereign in 1952, why did the USA, UK, France, and USSR have to sign the Two Plus Four Treaty in 1990 to explicitly "terminate their rights and responsibilities in relation to Berlin and Germany as a whole" and restore full sovereignty?

Your Canada Strawman, the 51 year delay was down to internal Canadian politics, Britain wasn't asserting imperial control, the best way to describe the situation is we were the benign custodian of their constitution until such a time they could come to an agreement internally. It's just not comparable to the conditions Germany were under between 1952/55 and 1990. We had no international veto power over Canada, we didn't place thousands of troops in Ottawa to ensure compliance. It's a bad faith argument.

I also never asserted that NATO command itself implies occupation, so stop putting words in my mouth. Modern NATO members voluntarily host foreign forces under standard bilateral agreements that they can terminate at will. West Germany did not have that choice. Conflating standard NATO stationing with retained Allied occupation rights is just another attempt to blur the reality of the situation.

Back to Gaza, these goalposts are covering some ground. You went from claiming the PA was given "no warning" and told "here's the keys" to now arguing that 20 months of notice plus 2 full years on the ground wasn't enough time because "South Africa took four years." For the record, South Africa is another Strawman and false equivalence.

Claiming the PA had "no transitional support" is another easily disproved claim. Presumably you've heard of the USSC? They and international allies spent millions training, equipping, and structuring PA security forces starting in 2005. The PA had international backing, billions in aid, US training, and tens of thousands of armed personnel.

They didn't lose power in Gaza because they lacked time, notice, or training. They lost because Hamas was better armed, more ruthless, and defeated them in a civil war that lasted less than a week, I've no idea how many times this needs to be reiterated? A four-year "negotiated transition" written down, wouldn't have changed the firepower on the ground in 2007, it's pie in the sky to think it would now in the West Bank. The people that you are suggesting the Israelis should be at the table with are being propped up by the IDF to survive. Make it make sense.
Reply
#48
(10-06-2026, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.

Why would they? I asked Jenny Davis out 3 times before I got the message 40-odd years ago.

Maybe Israel has got the message. October 7th seemed to ram it home.

It is remarkable that even after that you think Israel would want to come to the negotiating table.
Reply
#49
(10-06-2026, 02:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-06-2026, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.

Why would they?

Realpolitik.

(10-06-2026, 01:56 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-06-2026, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Who passed the German Emergency Acts, which Civillian Authority amended the German constitution? Pretty sure it wasn't the Allies. Did you bother to look up the Deutschlandvertrag when West German sovereignty and independence was formally established and accepted by the allies, which is why I referred to 1952? Reserved powers were not used by the allies in West Germany beyond that date. And I brought up Canada because it was functionally independent and sovereign after 1931, not 1982 when reserved powers that Westminster held but were never used were removed. And you have decided to assert that control over foreign troop movements under NATO command implies occupation ergo making that implication again.

And 6 months to form power structures with no transitional support to enforce control is not a transition. The PA being overthrown didn't happen overnight, did it? South Africa took four years to transition out of Apartheid, Eastern Croatia took 3 years and both of those had a formal transition of power to establish democratic legitimatacy.

Who passed the Emergency Acts? West Germany, they were forced to pass them because the Allies held reserved powers over them. The Deutschlandvertrag explicitly stated in Article 5 that Allied reserved intervention powers would remain active until West Germany passed internal emergency laws satisfactory to the Allies. Passing those acts was the literal price the Allies demanded to relinquish that specific piece of occupation authority, it took Bonn 23 years to comply.

You like a question, so here's mine, if West Germany became fully sovereign in 1952, why did the USA, UK, France, and USSR have to sign the Two Plus Four Treaty in 1990 to explicitly "terminate their rights and responsibilities in relation to Berlin and Germany as a whole" and restore full sovereignty?

Your Canada Strawman, the 51 year delay was down to internal Canadian politics, Britain wasn't asserting imperial control, the best way to describe the situation is we were the benign custodian of their constitution until such a time they could come to an agreement internally. It's just not comparable to the conditions Germany were under between 1952/55 and 1990. We had no international veto power over Canada, we didn't place thousands of troops in Ottawa to ensure compliance. It's a bad faith argument.

I also never asserted that NATO command itself implies occupation, so stop putting words in my mouth. Modern NATO members voluntarily host foreign forces under standard bilateral agreements that they can terminate at will. West Germany did not have that choice. Conflating standard NATO stationing with retained Allied occupation rights is just another attempt to blur the reality of the situation.

Back to Gaza, these goalposts are covering some ground. You went from claiming the PA was given "no warning" and told "here's the keys" to now arguing that 20 months of notice plus 2 full years on the ground wasn't enough time because "South Africa took four years." For the record, South Africa is another Strawman and false equivalence.

Claiming the PA had "no transitional support" is another easily disproved claim. Presumably you've heard of the USSC? They and international allies spent millions training, equipping, and structuring PA security forces starting in 2005. The PA had international backing, billions in aid, US training, and tens of thousands of armed personnel.

They didn't lose power in Gaza because they lacked time, notice, or training. They lost because Hamas was better armed, more ruthless, and defeated them in a civil war that lasted less than a week, I've no idea how many times this needs to be reiterated? A four-year "negotiated transition" written down, wouldn't have changed the firepower on the ground in 2007, it's pie in the sky to think it would now in the West Bank. The people that you are suggesting the Israelis should be at the table with are being propped up by the IDF to survive. Make it make sense.

Because East Germany was completely separate and West Berlin was not a de-jure part of West Germany.

The Deutschlandvertrag also explicitly stated that West Germany was now a sovereign and independent nation no longer under occupation. Which, you know, is my point? If you want to play a game of legal bullshit then you'd best not ignore the foundational document establishing West German sovereignty that clearly outlines the end of the occupation of West Germany. That is why West Germany was able to amend their constitution, occupied countries cannot legislate to amend their constitutional frameworks as they're under occupation. That is why I brought up Canada which was functionally independent and no longer a dominion or colony despite Westminster retaining reserved powers.

And do you read everything literally? Have you heard of hyperbole? Do you seriously think that the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza involved then literally handing keys over? Fucking hell man, learn to read subtext, the point is that the PA were not able to establish control via established structures to enable a transition to a consolidated administration and that is what created a power vacuum which is what Hamas exploited. Coups happen because there is a power vacuum that is being exploited. It doesn't matter if you are armed if you're not transitioned into power, control and power isn't to have fucking weapons.

And I don't think you know what a straw man is. You can't straw man yourself. Giving examples of things is not a straw man. I'll give you an example of a straw man, for the record, you deliberately distorting what I'm saying about not enough time to establish control and governance by quoting out of context.
Reply
#50
(10-06-2026, 11:27 AM)Protheroet Wrote: Anyway, back to the OP. How about those nasty Greens? Who'd have thought allowing entryists into the party would breed rampant extremism. That hasn't happened under a populist left wing leader before has it? Oh....

When you talk of entryism what you are actually describing is a quadrupling of its membership in a year. Who would have thought that political parties would seek to increase the number of people who support it. Maybe the Conservatives are the exception with shadow ministers making speeches in front of half empty conference halls, and that’s being generous.

The problem with the Greens is they are too loose with their internal procedures. To get to vote on this motion all you need to do was buy a ticket for that particular session of the conference where the vote takes place. Even more alarming is that motions passed by conference become party policy. It's easy to see how a small determined group could get their particular hobby horse policy adopted as party policy. 

Worth noting that approximately 0.5% of the membership voted in favour of this motion. I hope and expect this motion to be reversed at the Spring conference.

But it remains the case that whilst this motion remains party policy I would find it difficult to vote Green. Just as well that I don't live in Holborn and St Pancras, not sure I would be going to the polling station
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)