Left Wing politics at its most juvenile
#31
(10-05-2026, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 04:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. Jordan and Egypt endorse the two-state solution. Syria has opened up diplomatic channels with Israel despite the Golan Heights. What you've posted is irrelevant to the current situation.

What you're saying is the same light as saying that modern Western European relations would never happen because of historic Franco-German relations from Prussia right up to WWII.

This analogy is one of the worst I've ever seen on here and makes no sense, in fact the two situations are completely non-analogous.

Aside from that, the PA is a paper tiger, no elections since 2005 and considering the geography of Area A, their rule is only really secure in Ramallah. Their co-operation with the IDF is necessary to keep them in power. As intimated, they already don't control vast swathes of the West Bank as it is.

There will be no return to the table for talks of a two-state solution following the events of October 7th without full demilitarisation of the other factions involved. The PA has no authority over either Hamas or PIJ or indeed dozens of other militia groups. It's a total non-starter.

Do you think that if you go back in 1939 and say within 30 years France and Germany will be in a voluntary economic union and not be laughed at? That is centuries of violent direct conflict right there to being cooperative neighbours with sovereignty over the Saarland and Alsace-Lorraine being sorted. It is perfectly analogous.

And the two-state solution is off the table because the Israeli government does not want it to be on the table, because the current Israeli PM has personally championed himself as being opposed to it. Hamas and PIJ are not the subject of negotiations, they are not and were not the recognised authority that Israel had been negotiating with for 4 years prior to the 2009 election.

What happened to Germany in 1945 to allow all that has followed? Now let me think, oh yes, total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and a decade of Allied occupation. When is this step going to happen in your analogy? Have a look at post-war China for a situation actually analogous.

You cannot negotiate with a paper tiger, day one of the new Palestinian State, free elections announced, fast forward a couple of months, hardline party (terrorists) who deny Israel's right to exist, win said election or just seize power, it wouldn't be the first time PA officials have taken headers off high buildings after all. Israel's enemies are back on their doorstep, 15 miles from Tel Aviv.

Your dismissal of Hamas and PIJ misses the point entirely. It doesn't matter who signs the treaty if they have neither the mandate of their own people (they don't) nor the power to enforce peace. Hamas and PIJ operate freely across the West Bank from the northern cities and refugee camps down to strongholds in Hebron and Bethlehem.
Reply
#32
Germany also lacked Islamist paymasters Jacko.
Reply
#33
(10-05-2026, 10:02 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 04:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. Jordan and Egypt endorse the two-state solution. Syria has opened up diplomatic channels with Israel despite the Golan Heights. What you've posted is irrelevant to the current situation.

What you're saying is the same light as saying that modern Western European relations would never happen because of historic Franco-German relations from Prussia right up to WWII.

This analogy is one of the worst I've ever seen on here and makes no sense, in fact the two situations are completely non-analogous.

Aside from that, the PA is a paper tiger, no elections since 2005 and considering the geography of Area A, their rule is only really secure in Ramallah. Their co-operation with the IDF is necessary to keep them in power. As intimated, they already don't control vast swathes of the West Bank as it is.

There will be no return to the table for talks of a two-state solution following the events of October 7th without full demilitarisation of the other factions involved. The PA has no authority over either Hamas or PIJ or indeed dozens of other militia groups. It's a total non-starter.

Do you think that if you go back in 1939 and say within 30 years France and Germany will be in a voluntary economic union and not be laughed at? That is centuries of violent direct conflict right there to being cooperative neighbours with sovereignty over the Saarland and Alsace-Lorraine being sorted. It is perfectly analogous.

And the two-state solution is off the table because the Israeli government does not want it to be on the table, because the current Israeli PM has personally championed himself as being opposed to it. Hamas and PIJ are not the subject of negotiations, they are not and were not the recognised authority that Israel had been negotiating with for 4 years prior to the 2009 election.

What happened to Germany in 1945 to allow all that has followed? Now let me think, oh yes, total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and a decade of Allied occupation. When is this step going to happen in your analogy? Have a look at post-war China for a situation actually analogous.

You cannot negotiate with a paper tiger, day one of the new Palestinian State, free elections announced, fast forward a couple of months, hardline party (terrorists) who deny Israel's right to exist, win said election or just seize power, it wouldn't be the first time PA officials have taken headers off high buildings after all. Israel's enemies are back on their doorstep, 15 miles from Tel Aviv.

Your dismissal of Hamas and PIJ misses the point entirely. It doesn't matter who signs the treaty if they have neither the mandate of their own people (they don't) nor the power to enforce peace. Hamas and PIJ operate freely across the West Bank from the northern cities and refugee camps down to strongholds in Hebron and Bethlehem.

Germany suffered total defeat, surrendered unconditionally and was completely demilitarised after WWI. That didn't magically improve Franco-German relations nor did it prevent WWII.

One of the biggest things undermining PA authority and support is the conduct of the Israeli state in the West Bank. You are choosing to ignore cause and effect.

(10-05-2026, 09:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Then they probably also know that Hamas is the de facto leadership in Gaza, and nothing the wholly illegitimate PA says or does will change that.

They weren't negotiating with Hamas, Olmert was negotiating with the PA and Lapid did open dialogue on negotiations with Abbas, both times were scuppered by Netanyahu being elected calling it all off.
Reply
#34
(10-06-2026, 08:01 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 10:02 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 04:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And as of 2026 the PA endorses the two-state solution and cooperates with the Israeli state on security matters in the West Bank which entirely contradicts your point. Jordan and Egypt endorse the two-state solution. Syria has opened up diplomatic channels with Israel despite the Golan Heights. What you've posted is irrelevant to the current situation.

What you're saying is the same light as saying that modern Western European relations would never happen because of historic Franco-German relations from Prussia right up to WWII.

This analogy is one of the worst I've ever seen on here and makes no sense, in fact the two situations are completely non-analogous.

Aside from that, the PA is a paper tiger, no elections since 2005 and considering the geography of Area A, their rule is only really secure in Ramallah. Their co-operation with the IDF is necessary to keep them in power. As intimated, they already don't control vast swathes of the West Bank as it is.

There will be no return to the table for talks of a two-state solution following the events of October 7th without full demilitarisation of the other factions involved. The PA has no authority over either Hamas or PIJ or indeed dozens of other militia groups. It's a total non-starter.

Do you think that if you go back in 1939 and say within 30 years France and Germany will be in a voluntary economic union and not be laughed at? That is centuries of violent direct conflict right there to being cooperative neighbours with sovereignty over the Saarland and Alsace-Lorraine being sorted. It is perfectly analogous.

And the two-state solution is off the table because the Israeli government does not want it to be on the table, because the current Israeli PM has personally championed himself as being opposed to it. Hamas and PIJ are not the subject of negotiations, they are not and were not the recognised authority that Israel had been negotiating with for 4 years prior to the 2009 election.

What happened to Germany in 1945 to allow all that has followed? Now let me think, oh yes, total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and a decade of Allied occupation. When is this step going to happen in your analogy? Have a look at post-war China for a situation actually analogous.

You cannot negotiate with a paper tiger, day one of the new Palestinian State, free elections announced, fast forward a couple of months, hardline party (terrorists) who deny Israel's right to exist, win said election or just seize power, it wouldn't be the first time PA officials have taken headers off high buildings after all. Israel's enemies are back on their doorstep, 15 miles from Tel Aviv.

Your dismissal of Hamas and PIJ misses the point entirely. It doesn't matter who signs the treaty if they have neither the mandate of their own people (they don't) nor the power to enforce peace. Hamas and PIJ operate freely across the West Bank from the northern cities and refugee camps down to strongholds in Hebron and Bethlehem.

Germany suffered total defeat, surrendered unconditionally and was completely demilitarised after WWI. That didn't magically improve Franco-German relations nor did it prevent WWII.

One of the biggest things undermining PA authority and support is the conduct of the Israeli state in the West Bank. You are choosing to ignore cause and effect.
Doubling down on being completely wrong on both issues is a bold strategy.

Germany was left with a standing army of 100k after Versailles. They were never occupied, and their military capabilities were never dismantled. The terms of Versailles are actually one of the reasons the Third Reich was able to re-arm and rise to power so quickly. Total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and occupation, categorically only happened in 1945.

As stated, the PA is propped up by the IDF, does it harm them with the populace? Yes of course, to many Palestinians they look like quislings, but if you want to see cause and effect in action look at what happened when the IDF withdrew every soldier and settlement from Gaza in 2005. There's no doubt the same thing would happen in the West Bank.

The PA will never be able to get a mandate or maintain the peace in a two-state solution.
Reply
#35
(10-06-2026, 08:30 AM)Jacko Wrote: if you want to see cause and effect in action look at what happened when the IDF withdrew every soldier and settlement from Gaza in 2005. There's no doubt the same thing would happen in the West Bank.

True.
Reply
#36
(10-06-2026, 08:30 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-06-2026, 08:01 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 10:02 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:04 PM)Jacko Wrote: This analogy is one of the worst I've ever seen on here and makes no sense, in fact the two situations are completely non-analogous.

Aside from that, the PA is a paper tiger, no elections since 2005 and considering the geography of Area A, their rule is only really secure in Ramallah. Their co-operation with the IDF is necessary to keep them in power. As intimated, they already don't control vast swathes of the West Bank as it is.

There will be no return to the table for talks of a two-state solution following the events of October 7th without full demilitarisation of the other factions involved. The PA has no authority over either Hamas or PIJ or indeed dozens of other militia groups. It's a total non-starter.

Do you think that if you go back in 1939 and say within 30 years France and Germany will be in a voluntary economic union and not be laughed at? That is centuries of violent direct conflict right there to being cooperative neighbours with sovereignty over the Saarland and Alsace-Lorraine being sorted. It is perfectly analogous.

And the two-state solution is off the table because the Israeli government does not want it to be on the table, because the current Israeli PM has personally championed himself as being opposed to it. Hamas and PIJ are not the subject of negotiations, they are not and were not the recognised authority that Israel had been negotiating with for 4 years prior to the 2009 election.

What happened to Germany in 1945 to allow all that has followed? Now let me think, oh yes, total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and a decade of Allied occupation. When is this step going to happen in your analogy? Have a look at post-war China for a situation actually analogous.

You cannot negotiate with a paper tiger, day one of the new Palestinian State, free elections announced, fast forward a couple of months, hardline party (terrorists) who deny Israel's right to exist, win said election or just seize power, it wouldn't be the first time PA officials have taken headers off high buildings after all. Israel's enemies are back on their doorstep, 15 miles from Tel Aviv.

Your dismissal of Hamas and PIJ misses the point entirely. It doesn't matter who signs the treaty if they have neither the mandate of their own people (they don't) nor the power to enforce peace. Hamas and PIJ operate freely across the West Bank from the northern cities and refugee camps down to strongholds in Hebron and Bethlehem.

Germany suffered total defeat, surrendered unconditionally and was completely demilitarised after WWI. That didn't magically improve Franco-German relations nor did it prevent WWII.

One of the biggest things undermining PA authority and support is the conduct of the Israeli state in the West Bank. You are choosing to ignore cause and effect.
Doubling down on being completely wrong on both issues is a bold strategy.

Germany was left with a standing army of 100k after Versailles. They were never occupied, and their military capabilities were never dismantled. The terms of Versailles are actually one of the reasons the Third Reich was able to re-arm and rise to power so quickly. Total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and occupation, categorically only happened in 1945.

As stated, the PA is propped up by the IDF, does it harm them with the populace? Yes of course, to many Palestinians they look like quislings, but if you want to see cause and effect in action look at what happened when the IDF withdrew every soldier and settlement from Gaza in 2005. There's no doubt the same thing would happen in the West Bank.

The PA will never be able to get a mandate or maintain the peace in a two-state solution.

Germany was occupied by France after WWI, for longer than the post-WWII allied occupation lasted for. West German rearmament began in 1950 despite French protestations, naval and aerial rearmament happened quicker post WWII than what happened post-WWI.

And what happened in Gaza was there was a power vacuum caused by a lack of political power of the PA in Gaza which was subsequently filled by a terrorist group, if there is no power vacuum created in the West Bank and the PA is allowed to govern then that can't happen. Again, you are deliberately ignoring cause and effect.

Also, did you seriously just try to justify the West Bank settlements and occupation?
Reply
#37
(10-06-2026, 09:07 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-06-2026, 08:30 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-06-2026, 08:01 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 10:02 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-05-2026, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you think that if you go back in 1939 and say within 30 years France and Germany will be in a voluntary economic union and not be laughed at? That is centuries of violent direct conflict right there to being cooperative neighbours with sovereignty over the Saarland and Alsace-Lorraine being sorted. It is perfectly analogous.

And the two-state solution is off the table because the Israeli government does not want it to be on the table, because the current Israeli PM has personally championed himself as being opposed to it. Hamas and PIJ are not the subject of negotiations, they are not and were not the recognised authority that Israel had been negotiating with for 4 years prior to the 2009 election.

What happened to Germany in 1945 to allow all that has followed? Now let me think, oh yes, total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and a decade of Allied occupation. When is this step going to happen in your analogy? Have a look at post-war China for a situation actually analogous.

You cannot negotiate with a paper tiger, day one of the new Palestinian State, free elections announced, fast forward a couple of months, hardline party (terrorists) who deny Israel's right to exist, win said election or just seize power, it wouldn't be the first time PA officials have taken headers off high buildings after all. Israel's enemies are back on their doorstep, 15 miles from Tel Aviv.

Your dismissal of Hamas and PIJ misses the point entirely. It doesn't matter who signs the treaty if they have neither the mandate of their own people (they don't) nor the power to enforce peace. Hamas and PIJ operate freely across the West Bank from the northern cities and refugee camps down to strongholds in Hebron and Bethlehem.

Germany suffered total defeat, surrendered unconditionally and was completely demilitarised after WWI. That didn't magically improve Franco-German relations nor did it prevent WWII.

One of the biggest things undermining PA authority and support is the conduct of the Israeli state in the West Bank. You are choosing to ignore cause and effect.
Doubling down on being completely wrong on both issues is a bold strategy.

Germany was left with a standing army of 100k after Versailles. They were never occupied, and their military capabilities were never dismantled. The terms of Versailles are actually one of the reasons the Third Reich was able to re-arm and rise to power so quickly. Total defeat, unconditional surrender, complete demilitarisation, and occupation, categorically only happened in 1945.

As stated, the PA is propped up by the IDF, does it harm them with the populace? Yes of course, to many Palestinians they look like quislings, but if you want to see cause and effect in action look at what happened when the IDF withdrew every soldier and settlement from Gaza in 2005. There's no doubt the same thing would happen in the West Bank.

The PA will never be able to get a mandate or maintain the peace in a two-state solution.

Germany was occupied by France after WWI, for longer than the post-WWII allied occupation lasted for. West German rearmament began in 1950 despite French protestations, naval and aerial rearmament happened quicker post WWII than what happened post-WWI.

And what happened in Gaza was there was a power vacuum caused by a lack of political power of the PA in Gaza which was subsequently filled by a terrorist group, if there is no power vacuum created in the West Bank and the PA is allowed to govern then that can't happen. Again, you are deliberately ignoring cause and effect.

Also, did you seriously just try to justify the West Bank settlements and occupation?

Can always tell when you're struggling BB, that dog with a bone, fixation on a specific aspect of the debate starts to slip.

In this case you keep moving the goalposts as your history keeps collapsing.

The Allied occupation after WW2 lasted for 45 years. France taking back Alsace-Lorraine and occupying the Saarland and Rhineland until 1930 (so 12 years) following WW1 were a combination of restoring their borders, creating a military buffer zone and reparations after the German army flooded coal mines during their retreat. So three regional border enforcements that are incomparable with the complete dissolution and removal of the German state and the four-power split of the entire country. The fact it collapsed into the Cold War and then the 1949 partition is irrelevant. It didn't officially end until 1990. Both East and West Germany were re-armed by their occupiers.

A power vacuum is exactly what would happen again, because the PA hasn't got anywhere near the firepower of armed terror groups Hamas and PIJ, they have lost control of the north of the West Bank even with IDF assistance. They are unable to shift them out of Hebron and Bethlehem much closer to home.

In 2005 the IDF left Gaza lock, stock and barrel. Hamas started chucking the PA off buildings, and seized power eventually culminating in October 7th. This will never be allowed to happen again.

The part I've put in bold is wishful thinking imo, they are unable to govern without the IDF now, a piece of paper saying they are a state will not change that reality. Finally, no, pointing out the objective reality of the security situation on the ground isn't 'trying to justify' anything.
Reply
#38
The allied occupation of West Germany ended in 1952 with exception of the Saarland which was handed over from French jurisdiction to West Germany in 1957 three years after the process to establish civillian leadership in both West and East Germany began. West German militarisation happened under its civilian leadership as part of NATO with air and naval rearmament in 1956. What the hell are you on about? Do you know what occupation means? Do you think that the Baltics are occupied right now instead of being sovereign over the defence and membership of NATO or something?

And the PNA were not allowed to transition into control over Gaza under the disengagement plan which is what created the power vacuum. The whole point of a negotiated settlement and transition is to literally avoid a power vacuum being created as was caused by the unilateral Israeli actions in the mid-2000s. Again, what the hell are you on about? Do you think that a two-state solution wouldn't involve a transition period to establish political structures or something?

You can't just invent fantasies and false equivalences in your own head to justify your point.
Reply
#39
“You can't just invent fantasies and false equivalences in your own head to justify your point.”

I don’t think there would be much Jacko left without this. He even stretches it to goalkeeping posts.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#40
(10-06-2026, 10:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The allied occupation of West Germany ended in 1952 with exception of the Saarland which was handed over from French jurisdiction to West Germany in 1957 three years after the process to establish civillian leadership in both West and East Germany began. West German militarisation happened under its civilian leadership as part of NATO with air and naval rearmament in 1956. What the hell are you on about? Do you know what occupation means? Do you think that the Baltics are occupied right now instead of being sovereign over the defence and membership of NATO or something?

And the PNA were not allowed to transition into control over Gaza under the disengagement plan which is what created the power vacuum. The whole point of a negotiated settlement and transition is to literally avoid a power vacuum being created as was caused by the unilateral Israeli actions in the mid-2000s. Again, what the hell are you on about? Do you think that a two-state solution wouldn't involve a transition period to establish political structures or something?

You can't just invent fantasies and false equivalences in your own head to justify your point.

Word games now then, as opposed to accepting the legal reality, a bit desperate fella, but do keep digging.

You are mistaking the lifting of day-to-day military administration for full legal sovereignty. The Bonn-Paris Conventions granted West Germany internal self-governance, but the Allied powers explicitly retained reserved occupation rights over foreign affairs, military deployment, Berlin, and German reunification. West Germany was brought into NATO as a heavily monitored frontline state under Western command, not as a sovereign nation. Full, unrestricted German sovereignty was legally restored only under the Two Plus Four Treaty in 1990. Comparing post-WW2 occupied Germany to modern Baltic NATO members is an actual false equivalence, well played, that final sentence is serving you well...

Back to Gaza then, this 'lack of a negotiated transition' line is a total rewrite of history.

Israel pulled out every soldier and settler in 2005. The PA was handed full internal civil control, the infrastructure, and the administrative apparatus. They had thousands of armed security forces on the ground. What happened in 2007 wasn't an administrative 'vacuum'. PA Security forces were defeated by Hamas in a brutal civil war, they then sent PA officials tumbling off the top of high buildings, it took them less than a week.

The idea that adding a 'negotiated transition' on paper magically equips a weak, corrupt PA to defeat Hamas or PIJ in Hebron or the north is pure fantasy, again well done on that final sentence, looking better and better. If the PA cannot secure the West Bank with the IDF propping them up, they will not survive a 'transition period'.

Straws, clutching at.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)