Credit to the club where it's due: Sam Johnstone
#1
When Sam Johnstone was bought, the club said this was the sort of investment we needed to make in the future, buying a young (for a GK), promising player and being able to sell him on for a profit.

There were howls from certain corners (notably on twotter) that we'd overpaid, that he was a poor buy etc. 

They've gone very quiet now. 

We've talked a lot about the things the club has got wrong recently and fair enough. But Johnstone has proven to be an excellent purchase and a great advert to the sort of player development we can provide. Pereira the same btw, tv does not do justice to how much he's improved since last season.

(05-25-2021, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: It’s just a shame we have failed to employ that logic with many of our other signings.

For all the clamour for us to use the overseas market, the division that has consistently produced the most successful players in the PL is the Championship... this ought to be our main hunting ground.

Correct. Likewise, we should be using League 1 for the Championship, just look at Townsend.
Reply
#2
(05-25-2021, 07:19 PM)Squid Wrote: When Sam Johnstone was bought, the club said this was the sort of investment we needed to make in the future, buying a young (for a GK), promising player and being able to sell him on for a profit.

There were howls from certain corners (notably on twotter) that we'd overpaid, that he was a poor buy etc. 

They've gone very quiet now. 

We've talked a lot about the things the club has got wrong recently and fair enough. But Johnstone has proven to be an excellent purchase and a great advert to the sort of player development we can provide. Pereira the same btw, tv does not do justice to how much he's improved since last season.

With TWO up and comimg excellent young keepers it's great we are in a position to be able sell Johnstone.
Reply
#3
It's great that we have TWO excellent keepers who can take the nimber 1 shirt.
Nice to know Sam has done well, but we are happy for him to move.
Reply
#4
It's great that we have TWO excellent keepers who can take the nimber 1 shirt.
Nice to know Sam has done well, but we are happy for him to move.
Reply
#5
It’s just a shame we have failed to employ that logic with many of our other signings.

For all the clamour for us to use the overseas market, the division that has consistently produced the most successful players in the PL is the Championship... this ought to be our main hunting ground.
Reply
#6
Squid Wrote:When Sam Johnstone was bought, the club said this was the sort of investment we needed to make in the future, buying a young (for a GK), promising player and being able to sell him on for a profit.

There were howls from certain corners (notably on twotter) that we'd overpaid, that he was a poor buy etc. 

They've gone very quiet now. 

We've talked a lot about the things the club has got wrong recently and fair enough. But Johnstone has proven to be an excellent purchase and a great advert to the sort of player development we can provide. Pereira the same btw, tv does not do justice to how much he's improved since last season.
….and best of all, we bought him from under the nose of villa while they were fighting off the bailiffs.
Reply
#7
No credit until the sale is made and we know how well they've done on the fee... if we get £10m (I think he's worth more now) remember that £1.5m will go to Man U. And we paid £6m for him...if we get £20m then the club will deserve some credit as you outline.

Until he is sold there is no credit as you describe.
Reply
#8
(05-25-2021, 07:42 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Squid Wrote:When Sam Johnstone was bought, the club said this was the sort of investment we needed to make in the future, buying a young (for a GK), promising player and being able to sell him on for a profit.

There were howls from certain corners (notably on twotter) that we'd overpaid, that he was a poor buy etc. 

They've gone very quiet now. 

We've talked a lot about the things the club has got wrong recently and fair enough. But Johnstone has proven to be an excellent purchase and a great advert to the sort of player development we can provide. Pereira the same btw, tv does not do justice to how much he's improved since last season.
….and best of all, we bought him from under the nose of villa while they were fighting off the bailiffs.

I would love him to go there for some ridiculous fee. Top spunking on a player they could have had if they weren't broke at the time.
Reply
#9
(05-25-2021, 08:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote: No credit until the sale is made and we know how well they've done on the fee... if we get £10m (I think he's worth more now) remember that £1.5m will go to Man U. And we paid £6m for him...if we get £20m then the club will deserve some credit as you outline.

Until he is sold there is no credit as you describe.

I think club would have been in a stronger position had we given him a new deal in Summer.

With 12m left I can’t see the potential £30m we could have got had he been on a long term deal.
Reply
#10
(05-25-2021, 07:19 PM)Squid Wrote: When Sam Johnstone was bought, the club said this was the sort of investment we needed to make in the future, buying a young (for a GK), promising player and being able to sell him on for a profit.

There were howls from certain corners (notably on twotter) that we'd overpaid, that he was a poor buy etc. 

They've gone very quiet now. 

We've talked a lot about the things the club has got wrong recently and fair enough. But Johnstone has proven to be an excellent purchase and a great advert to the sort of player development we can provide. Pereira the same btw, tv does not do justice to how much he's improved since last season.

(05-25-2021, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: It’s just a shame we have failed to employ that logic with many of our other signings.

For all the clamour for us to use the overseas market, the division that has consistently produced the most successful players in the PL is the Championship... this ought to be our main hunting ground.

Correct. Likewise, we should be using League 1 for the Championship, just look at Townsend.

Never forget the poster who after Johnstone’s debut against Bolton labelled him “the worst Albion keeper since Paul Crichton”.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: