Shareholders update S4A.
#1
Update from S4A

This letter has been sent to Xu Ken (known to colleagues as Ken) from shareholders today.

Also please note S4A are also in regular communications with A4A.

No ridiculous comments please. Sharing with those who may well be interested. Those who are not, do yourself a favour, don’t bother reading it.

Cheers all.



Dear Ken
 
I hope you and your family are well.
 
Wisdom Smart Loan
 
We are now clearly past 'early in the New Year' by any reasonable person's measure. We have still not received confirmation that the highly contentious loan from Group to Wisdom Smart Corporation Limited ('the Wisdom Smart Loan') has been repaid.
 
I do not intend to repeat the detailed comment regarding the decision to make and previous failure to obtain repayment of the loan. That has already been covered in previous correspondence between us, which will continue, as required. I would, however, comment that the MSD Loan brings into sharp focus the issues around the Wisdom Smart Loan. The former is a secured loan at a significant interest rate. That is what I would expect to see. The latter is not secured and was not made at commercial rate for an unsecured loan to a company in a foreign jurisdiction. 
 
This email instead concentrates on establishing the steps you have taken recently/are planning to take to obtain the long overdue re-payment of the Wisdom Smart Loan. I understand from various sources that both yourself and Henry Pu have failed to respond to shareholders and supporters on correspondence on this issue and other issues and that people have been encouraged to channel their queries through Shareholders for Albion and/or Action for Albion. 
 
General comments:
1.  Please note that, whilst we act for the large majority of the independent shareholders, we do not act for all of the independent shareholders. Those who are not our members are entitled to contact you directly as shareholders.
 
2. Not all supporters will be members/followers of Action for Albion.
 
3. Whilst I believe that most fair-minded supporters and shareholders will recognise that Ron Gourlay has done and is doing everything that he can to obtain repayment of the Wisdom Smart Loan, the matter is not within his remit or control. Ron Gourlay is not a director of Group. You are the sole director of Group. You are also the controlling shareholders' representative at the football club.
           For the avoidance of doubt: we confirm that we do not consider Ron Gourlay responsible for any matters concerned with the Wisom Smart Loan.
4. You have not provided an update to the supporters and shareholders on the repayment at any time during 2023. There is a vacuum of information from you on what is an extremely important and serious matter.
 
5. I had advised our Committee to wait until the end of February 2023 to see if repayment was made, for various reasons, including demonstrating further (albeit undue) reasonableness and patience on our part and the part of supporters generally.
 
6. I attach a copy of the Special Resolution of Wisdom Smart Corporation Limited dated 27 May 2022 dealing with its capital reduction. You will either already be aware of this or should be aware of this. This allowed the capital of the company to be reduced by approximately £24,000,000 (twenty four million pounds) which is stated as 'being in excess of the requirements of the Company.' We are now left with an unpaid loan with this company.
     7. You will no doubt be aware of the Government's White Paper: 'A sustainable future - reforming club football governance.'
 
           8. There continues to be a great deal of negative press on national and local levels concerning our football club, including the Wisdom Smart Loan. This is clearly causing significant                                reputational damage to our great football club.
 
 
Please confirm no later than the close of business on 13 March 2023 the following:
a. Why you did not seek to enforce repayment upon becoming aware of the Special Resolution dated 27 May 2022. 
 
b. The steps you have taken to secure repayment of the Wisdom Smart Loan since 1 January 2023.
 
b. The further steps you are proposing to take to secure repayment as a matter of urgency.
 
c. If applicable - a firm date on which you expect cleared funds to be in the account of Group, by way of full repayment of the Wisdom Smart Loan (including all capital and interest due).
 
d. That repayment monies will immediately be transferred to Club's account, including all interest recieved by Group.  You and/or another director of Club at the time (but not Ron Gourlay, who was not a director of Club at that time), sanctioned moving Club's money to Group to facilitate making of the Wisdom Smart Loan.
 
e. Whether or not that there is a fit for purpose and validly executed loan agreement for the Wisdom Smart Loan in existence. 
 
I confirm that the above reflects the immediatequestions which our members require a response to. I reserve the right to raise further questions in due course. 



Given your preference for all enquiries on these matters to be channelled via Shareholders for Albion, the Committee will, of course, need to share the full text of this email and your response with our membership, in order to evidence that their concerns have been raised and to pass on your responses.
 
You will no doubt be aware of your fiduciary duties as a director of Club and Group on this matter. These are personal duties. We have discussed this previously and I will not discuss further here due to the need to share the text more widely. Leaving aside any further detailed discussion relating to the grant of the loan and its terms, it would be legitimate to conclude that failure to enforce repayment per the terms of the loan would amount to a breach of fiduciary duty. The monies are clearly needed by the football club and always have been. It was not in the interests of the football club to make the loan.  It is also legitimate to conclude that the fact that the Club has now had to take out the MSD loan exacerbates the seriousness of the matter.
 
Accounts Queries and Warmfront Loan
 
I reserve the right to follow up on salient outstanding accounts/financial questions which still remain outstanding further to your letter dated 15 September 2022, once the accounts for the year ended 30 June 2022 have been lodged. Ron Gourlay has confirmed this will be no later than 31 March 2023 in respect of Club and Group. For now, however, I need to raise the following:
 
Your letter dated 15 September 2022 stated at 1.6:
"In relation to the Warmfront Loan, I will make enquiries of Mr Li and provide further information when I can." Note to our members: this is Mr Li, not Mr Lai.
 
We are yet to hear from you further on this point, almost six months on. Please can you provide a substantive response by return. 
 
Annual General Meetings
 
As discussed on many occasions previously, please confirm in writing whether or not you will reinstate the (annual) General Meetings (at The Hawthorns) for shareholders, which were abolished by Jeremy Peace, after he moved first moved the meetings  to London. If not, why not? We welcome Ron Gourlay's efforts in trying to increase transparency and accountability within the Club. We feel that this would be a further step in the right direction.
 
General
 
I have copied in the following on the bases stated:
i. Ron Gourlay and Ian Skidmore - for information only.
 
ii. Henry Pu - whilst it is noted that Mr Pu is not a statutory director of Club or Group,  given his role as 'Finance Director' these are clearly issues and concerns of shareholders and supporters which he needs to be aware of, as part of his job.
 
iii. David Baker as Chairman of Shareholders for Albion.
 
iv. Our solicitors, Gowling WLG.
 
The email addresses will not be included when including the text of this email in our members' update.
 
Kind regards
Reply
#2
Thanks for posting that Ronnie

Sadly, I have little faith in the loans being repaid and if they are, most likely funded from dividends as previously proposed in the last set of published accounts. Or the loans are repaid and a dividend made soon after.
Reply
#3
Thanks for the update. Let's see if there is a response this time.
Reply
#4
Thanks for the update.

Sadly I don't ever see the loans to Wisdom ever being repaid, and I see significant issues with the 20 million loan against the club.
Reply
#5
A lot of words just to ask 'where's the money gone, Tom?'.

In seriousness, appreciate the update.
Reply
#6
(03-06-2023, 06:14 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Thanks for the update.

Sadly I don't ever see the loans to Wisdom ever being repaid, and I see significant issues with the 20 million loan against the club.

+1

Thanks for the update none the less Ronnie.
Reply
#7
Thanks for the update. Every penny will count now our parachute payments are ending.
Reply
#8
Thanks Ronnie. Keep gooin son.
Reply
#9
Superb work. Tighten the screw make them feel uncomfortable. Probably make no difference but make those fuckers squirm
Reply
#10
Don’t worry they will crumble after Saturday’s Protest
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)