Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-16-2024, 07:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-16-2024, 09:12 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
Are these really serious policies by a Labour Party? I know Labour seem to be hell bent in out Torying the Tories but frankly it’s embarrassing, crude and crass. ‘Fat jabs’ fail to address the reasons for obesity and forcing someone with the threat of benefit sanctions in hospital to improve their C.V. whilst in hospital for severe mental health problems is Dickensian.
Anyone who defends this nonsense who voted Labour is no better than those who defended the last 14 yrs of shite under the last government.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
All governments of the left see the population as economic drones. Why does this surprise you? They'll be sending "job coaches" onto mental health wards soon.
Oh...
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
10-17-2024, 07:26 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2024, 07:27 AM by Pontificator.)
Isn't this just occupational therapy:
Occupational therapy can help you with practical tasks if you:
are physically disabled
are recovering from an illness or operation
have learning disabilities
have mental health problems
are getting older
Occupational therapists work with people of all ages and can look at all aspects of daily life in your home, school or workplace.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-17-2024, 07:26 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Isn't this just occupational therapy:
Occupational therapy can help you with practical tasks if you:
are physically disabled
are recovering from an illness or operation
have learning disabilities
have mental health problems
are getting older
Occupational therapists work with people of all ages and can look at all aspects of daily life in your home, school or workplace.
No, occupational therapy is there when you are recovering from illness, it’s not there as some stipulation with regards to the benefits you qualify for, because you aren’t fit for work because erm you’re in a hospital due to mental health problems. The fat jab is equally as crass, it fails to address the reason people have put on weight, just a binary solution to a complex problem. As I said if Mel Stride has come up with these ideas Labour bobble hats would be against it because it’s a crass, blunt solution to complex problems.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-17-2024, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-17-2024, 07:26 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Isn't this just occupational therapy:
Occupational therapy can help you with practical tasks if you:
are physically disabled
are recovering from an illness or operation
have learning disabilities
have mental health problems
are getting older
Occupational therapists work with people of all ages and can look at all aspects of daily life in your home, school or workplace.
No, occupational therapy is there when you are recovering from illness, it’s not there as some stipulation with regards to the benefits you qualify for, because you aren’t fit for work because erm you’re in a hospital due to mental health problems. The fat jab is equally as crass, it fails to address the reason people have put on weight, just a binary solution to a complex problem. As I said if Mel Stride has come up with these ideas Labour bobble hats would be against it because it’s a crass, blunt solution to complex problems.
Surely just making people better isn't really a great end goal, is it? If making them better allows them to do something more constructive with their lives, feel fulfilled, then this is a better aim? The problem with weight issues for example, is that it's a downward spiral. Fatter you get, less you can do, get depressed, stuff more doughnuts. For me it's not a lot different to prescribing nicotine patches to get people off fags.
Posts: 11,920
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
10-17-2024, 08:32 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2024, 08:33 AM by CarlosCorbewrong.)
(10-17-2024, 08:28 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-17-2024, 07:26 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Isn't this just occupational therapy:
Occupational therapy can help you with practical tasks if you:
are physically disabled
are recovering from an illness or operation
have learning disabilities
have mental health problems
are getting older
Occupational therapists work with people of all ages and can look at all aspects of daily life in your home, school or workplace.
No, occupational therapy is there when you are recovering from illness, it’s not there as some stipulation with regards to the benefits you qualify for, because you aren’t fit for work because erm you’re in a hospital due to mental health problems. The fat jab is equally as crass, it fails to address the reason people have put on weight, just a binary solution to a complex problem. As I said if Mel Stride has come up with these ideas Labour bobble hats would be against it because it’s a crass, blunt solution to complex problems.
Surely just making people better isn't really a great end goal, is it? If making them better allows them to do something more constructive with their lives, feel fulfilled, then this is a better aim? The problem with weight issues for example, is that it's a downward spiral. Fatter you get, less you can do, get depressed, stuff more doughnuts. For me it's not a lot different to prescribing nicotine patches to get people off fags.
Except, in this case, if you refuse the nicotine patch - even if you're mentally or physically vulnerable, you could lose your benefits. That's the critical difference, if true.
And let's be honest, there is so much fluff and bluster about invented Labour policies, it's impossible to say... 39% CGT anyone?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-17-2024, 08:32 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:28 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-17-2024, 07:26 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Isn't this just occupational therapy:
Occupational therapy can help you with practical tasks if you:
are physically disabled
are recovering from an illness or operation
have learning disabilities
have mental health problems
are getting older
Occupational therapists work with people of all ages and can look at all aspects of daily life in your home, school or workplace.
No, occupational therapy is there when you are recovering from illness, it’s not there as some stipulation with regards to the benefits you qualify for, because you aren’t fit for work because erm you’re in a hospital due to mental health problems. The fat jab is equally as crass, it fails to address the reason people have put on weight, just a binary solution to a complex problem. As I said if Mel Stride has come up with these ideas Labour bobble hats would be against it because it’s a crass, blunt solution to complex problems.
Surely just making people better isn't really a great end goal, is it? If making them better allows them to do something more constructive with their lives, feel fulfilled, then this is a better aim? The problem with weight issues for example, is that it's a downward spiral. Fatter you get, less you can do, get depressed, stuff more doughnuts. For me it's not a lot different to prescribing nicotine patches to get people off fags.
Except, in this case, if you refuse the nicotine patch - even if you're mentally or physically vulnerable, you could lose your benefits. That's the critical difference, if true.
And let's be honest, there is so much fluff and bluster about invented Labour policies, it's impossible to say... 39% CGT anyone?
There are, of course, nuances in all of this but as a rule I'd say if you are unemployed and you don't try to gain employment then you should lose your benefits. There's no reason why others should pay for your sloth. If the reason you are unwell is that you are unable to then the state will provide the resources to get you to a position when you can work (whether this will be of a good enough standard is another thing). If you refuse to partake of this help then you lose your benefits. Loads of shades of grey here, granted, but is the above really that unfair?
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(10-17-2024, 08:49 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:32 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:28 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-17-2024, 07:26 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Isn't this just occupational therapy:
Occupational therapy can help you with practical tasks if you:
are physically disabled
are recovering from an illness or operation
have learning disabilities
have mental health problems
are getting older
Occupational therapists work with people of all ages and can look at all aspects of daily life in your home, school or workplace.
No, occupational therapy is there when you are recovering from illness, it’s not there as some stipulation with regards to the benefits you qualify for, because you aren’t fit for work because erm you’re in a hospital due to mental health problems. The fat jab is equally as crass, it fails to address the reason people have put on weight, just a binary solution to a complex problem. As I said if Mel Stride has come up with these ideas Labour bobble hats would be against it because it’s a crass, blunt solution to complex problems.
Surely just making people better isn't really a great end goal, is it? If making them better allows them to do something more constructive with their lives, feel fulfilled, then this is a better aim? The problem with weight issues for example, is that it's a downward spiral. Fatter you get, less you can do, get depressed, stuff more doughnuts. For me it's not a lot different to prescribing nicotine patches to get people off fags.
Except, in this case, if you refuse the nicotine patch - even if you're mentally or physically vulnerable, you could lose your benefits. That's the critical difference, if true.
And let's be honest, there is so much fluff and bluster about invented Labour policies, it's impossible to say... 39% CGT anyone?
There are, of course, nuances in all of this but as a rule I'd say if you are unemployed and you don't try to gain employment then you should lose your benefits. There's no reason why others should pay for your sloth. If the reason you are unwell is that you are unable to then the state will provide the resources to get you to a position when you can work (whether this will be of a good enough standard is another thing). If you refuse to partake of this help then you lose your benefits. Loads of shades of grey here, granted, but is the above really that unfair?
I think it's fair there's an inherent lack of trust in this given the terrible track record of the DWP taking away benefits from people who really do need the support that was taken away for seemingly arbitrary reasons coupled with the poor state of healthcare (and especially mental healthcare) that's required to manage a lot of conditions so people can work.
In principle it seems fine to me but I really don't think there's enough substance for me to trust that it's about the principle.
Posts: 11,920
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(10-17-2024, 08:57 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:49 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:32 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:28 AM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2024, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No, occupational therapy is there when you are recovering from illness, it’s not there as some stipulation with regards to the benefits you qualify for, because you aren’t fit for work because erm you’re in a hospital due to mental health problems. The fat jab is equally as crass, it fails to address the reason people have put on weight, just a binary solution to a complex problem. As I said if Mel Stride has come up with these ideas Labour bobble hats would be against it because it’s a crass, blunt solution to complex problems.
Surely just making people better isn't really a great end goal, is it? If making them better allows them to do something more constructive with their lives, feel fulfilled, then this is a better aim? The problem with weight issues for example, is that it's a downward spiral. Fatter you get, less you can do, get depressed, stuff more doughnuts. For me it's not a lot different to prescribing nicotine patches to get people off fags.
Except, in this case, if you refuse the nicotine patch - even if you're mentally or physically vulnerable, you could lose your benefits. That's the critical difference, if true.
And let's be honest, there is so much fluff and bluster about invented Labour policies, it's impossible to say... 39% CGT anyone?
There are, of course, nuances in all of this but as a rule I'd say if you are unemployed and you don't try to gain employment then you should lose your benefits. There's no reason why others should pay for your sloth. If the reason you are unwell is that you are unable to then the state will provide the resources to get you to a position when you can work (whether this will be of a good enough standard is another thing). If you refuse to partake of this help then you lose your benefits. Loads of shades of grey here, granted, but is the above really that unfair?
I think it's fair there's an inherent lack of trust in this given the terrible track record of the DWP taking away benefits from people who really do need the support that was taken away for seemingly arbitrary reasons coupled with the poor state of healthcare (and especially mental healthcare) that's required to manage a lot of conditions so people can work.
In principle it seems fine to me but I really don't think there's enough substance for me to trust that it's about the principle.
Hard to disagree with either Fido or BB's points. I would however add that there is a nuance about encouraging, supporting and threatening people into work when they've been feckless and doing the same when people are genuinely vulnerable. The threshold for admission onto a Mental Health ward is very high - they are much more complex than "slothenly".
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Agree. Plus given the lack of trust of the help on offer and how these things are pursued you'd probably end up in a negative situation where the contests of the decisions clog up the whole thing and effectively lose money as opposed to looking to gain by getting people off benefits. Having seen the piss-poor approach to looking after the missus' old man who is currently in respite "care" after leaving hospital I can only assume this is more standard than a bad example.
|