VAR has solved nothing?
#1
Not a fan of VAR at all. Cheering goals disallowed 2 minutes later, celebrating penalties that end up not being given. Really it’s just created more subjective debate.
Last night showed with or without it you’ll never clear up the talking points and people saying they were on the wrong side of a poor decision.
Last night we had a disallowed Norway goal, a goal for us that supposedly hit a wire in the sky, a penalty given that was not a clear and obvious error. Also, I’d almost forgotten, Kane looked to be fouled in the build up to the Norway goal. 
All of these could have gone either way. 
Technology really takes away more than it offers. In the big scheme these decisions even out and in a knockout competition there will always be a certain amount of luck involved. It does play a part.
Reply
#2
Agree. It didn't have to be this way but it is. I'd prefer to be without VAR altogether.
Reply
#3
I'm not a huge fan of VAR but must say it seems to be used far more effectively in the World Cups compared to league football where decisions take a ridiculous amount of time to make.

In terms of last night's VAR worked perfectly well and made all the right decisions. I don't think Kane was fouled in the lead up to their goal. For their disallowed goal Haaland clearly pushes Anderson out of the way. In terms of the England penalty Spence completely engineers the contact between him and the Norway player.

In the Arg-Swiss game Embolo was rightly sent off for being a cheat when originally the Argentine player was incorrectly booked.

VAR as a concept is fine. The issues with it are more with the incompetence of those implementing it.
Reply
#4
The Spence penalty incident was anything but clear and obvious. The ref had to stick with his initial decision. They’re now conning people into thinking you can’t put a part of your body in the way of an opponent getting to the ball. And people believe it. I can’t believe what I’m seeing and hearing. It’s what you’re taught to do from an early age. It’s the defending players job to not foul you by getting to tight or kicking or shoving you
Reply
#5
Is there any point in the ref going over to the screen, seems like every pitch side viewing is predictable and the ref goes with them.
Reply
#6
(07-12-2026, 11:10 AM)KRO Wrote: The Spence penalty incident was anything but clear and obvious. The ref had to stick with his initial decision. They’re now conning people into thinking you can’t put a part of your body in the way of an opponent getting to the ball. And people believe it. I can’t believe what I’m seeing and hearing. It’s what you’re taught to do from an early age. It’s the defending players job to not foul you by getting to tight or kicking or shoving you

It was not a penalty right decision by VAR it was clear and obvious that Spence put his foot across initiating the contact.
Just shows I’m not as one eyed as some think.
Reply
#7
I’m also in the fuck it off completely camp but sadly that’s not gonna happen
Raw Sausage
Reply
#8
I think we’re stuck now, because VAR is rubbish, but if you take it away then you’ll start to realise just how bad the refs are without it.

The only tangible positive from VAR is that now home advantage in the Prem has decreased significantly since its introduction, which suggests that sometimes it has helped reduce the bias towards the home team in big decisions.

I would happily scrap it, but get ready for truly crap referees
Reply
#9
(07-12-2026, 11:10 AM)KRO Wrote: The Spence penalty incident was anything but clear and obvious. The ref had to stick with his initial decision. They’re now conning people into thinking you can’t put a part of your body in the way of an opponent getting to the ball. And people believe it. I can’t believe what I’m seeing and hearing. It’s what you’re taught to do from an early age. It’s the defending players job to not foul you by getting to tight or kicking or shoving you

No. You CAN put your body in the way of an opponent if it's to shield the ball. You can't put your leg deliberately into where he's running so you both fall. That's a foul.
Reply
#10
(07-12-2026, 12:08 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Is there any point in the ref going over to the screen, seems like every pitch side viewing is predictable and the ref goes with them.
Purely a face saving exercise for the ref so it appears that he is making the final decision...its all bollocks
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: